Cat's Second Chance

Story Info
Has her soul mate returned?
1.8k words
4.39
20.6k
3
Share this Story

Font Size

Default Font Size

Font Spacing

Default Font Spacing

Font Face

Default Font Face

Reading Theme

Default Theme (White)
You need to Log In or Sign Up to have your customization saved in your Literotica profile.
PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

'I've got to be out of my mind,' she thought to herself. After all these years she doubted that they could just pick up where they'd left off. "Barbara, I don't know if I can do this." a nervous Cathryn said.

"Are you nuts?" Barbara shot back. "You're the envy of every fifty-something woman I know!"

Cathryn knew she was lucky. For years she and most of the single women she knew had tried every conceivable way to meet men. She dated regularly, but could not find that one special someone with whom to share her life. She had all but given up hope, when Mr. Right dropped into her life - or actually back into it.

"You know I really can't believe this whole thing." Cathryn continued.

"I know what you mean," Barbara chuckled as she shook her head "truth really is stranger than fiction."

"It's been so long, Barbara. He just called out of the blue and asked if he could see me. What can he want after all this time? What if he wants to pick up where we left off?"

Her pulse quickened at the thought. Although she had never given voice to it, Cathryn had cherished a secret fantasy that one day he would return and bring with him the love that she'd only known with him.

"But worse yet," she continued, "what if he doesn't?"

Cathryn's self confidence wavered. Although it had been many years since she'd seen Stephen, he held a special place in her heart. In fact, if she were honest with herself, she would admit that he was the reason she never found a lifemate. She unconsciously compared every man she dated with Stephen and found all lacking in one way or another. The truth was she wanted the magic that was hers and Stephen's alone.

"Listen, Cathryn," Barbara began, "Stephen was always a kind and considerate man and he was crazy in love with you. I'm positive he stayed away from you all these years on purpose. Given the circumstances, he knew it would be difficult for you to see him again. Even more, I think it was too painful for him to see you if you couldn't be together. If he wants to see you now, you'd better believe he's got more on his mind than a casual visit."

"I'm not the same woman I was then." Cathryn said worriedly. "I want to live up to the memories of that wonderful time. When he looks at me, I want him to see the woman he loved. What if he takes one look and wonders what he ever saw in me?"

"Highly unlikely." said Barbara, Cathryn's closest friend for more than thirty years. "Take a good hard look at yourself." Barbara turned Cathryn toward the mirror. "So, what's not to like?"

As Cathryn looked at the woman in the mirror, she saw a well-kept woman of indeterminate middle age with auburn hair cut in a shoulder length bob, a creamy complexion and a trim figure. In her own deep blue eyes, she saw anticipation, confusion, exhilaration and fear. Most importantly, she saw that the real Cathryn hadn't changed at all.

"I guess I look okay for my age but the woman he knew was 35 not 53. Will he find the 'character' lines around my eyes attractive? And what will he think when my body proves to him that gravity exists?"

"Very funny. . . lighten up, okay?" Barbara said. "First of all, you definitely don't look your age - although there'd be nothing wrong with that. And don't forget, your Prince Charming is no longer a youth of 25."

"No, he isn't. But, at 43, Stephen is a virile man just coming into his prime." Her normally resilient self-confidence and positive outlook started to fade. "My head knows that time and age should not make a difference but my heart's not so sure," Cathryn said, biting her lower lip.

Barbara saw the faraway look in Cathryn's eyes and knew she was remembering. For a moment Cathryn drifted back 18 years; to a time when she and Stephen had been so in love, their lives so entwined, that they thought and acted as one. The love they shared had been so alive, it was almost tangible. She smiled at the memory. Then the ever present sadness intruded and squeezed her heart . The remembered pain of their separation was so strong that it still had the power to cripple her.

"We had to separate." Cathryn thought out loud.

"I know." Barbara whispered.

Aware that she had been day dreaming, Cathryn snapped back to the present.

"There was just no place in my life for children." she explained to her friend. "I was 35, had a successful career and no matter how much I loved Stephen, I did not want to have children." Not for the first time, her reasons sounded hollow to her own ears.

"It was a little more complicated than that," her friend gently reminded.

"I didn't realized it at the time;" Cathryn acknowledged. " I just never connected my mother's death in childbirth to my decision to remain childless."

Barbara looked sympathetic. "You were only 3 years old, who could know the impact it would have on you?

"All I knew was that my mother went to the hospital to have my baby sister and never came back. Obviously, it left a lasting impression - what happened to my mother was not going to happen to me."

"Most of the men I'd dated were thrilled that I didn't want kids, but I never loved any of them. No. . . I fell hopelessly in love with Stephen

"And he wanted children more than anything ," her friend supplied.

Cathryn paused, "Yes, he did. At 25, he felt his life was just beginning and could not imagine that life without a family. What we wanted, what we needed was just too different. So . . . we parted company."

But it hadn't been that easy. When she told him she could not, in good conscience, marry him knowing she would never give him children, he was heartbroken. Stephen begged and pleaded with her to reconsider having a family.

"Didn't Stephen suggest that you adopt if you couldn't or wouldn't have children of your own?" Barbara asked.

"Yes. Although I never told him, I would have been willing to adopt, but I loved Stephen too much to ask him to give up what he wanted most - a child of his own flesh and blood . Besides, children were not the only issue."

She had wanted more than anything to be Stephen's wife. In her mind, though, there had been too much working against them. She thought they didn't stand a chance. .

Barbara reflected, "Stephen never seemed bothered by the ten year difference in your ages."

"That's true," Cathryn replied, "But I was afraid that one day he would feel differently." She knew that if he left her for a younger woman, the pain would surely kill her.

"So, when he asked me to marry him and be the mother of his children, I said 'no'. She knew it meant the end of the relationship. ' It was the hardest thing she had ever done', Cathryn thought, her blue eyes bright with the tears she shed a thousand times since he left.

"That's old news." Barbara snapped. "Get a grip on yourself, girlfriend. Now is not the time for useless tears. The Man is back in town and he's coming for you!"

Cathryn's butterflies started again. "I'm so nervous." she said as she started to pace.

"Slow down - you'll wear out the carpet." Barbara admonished. "Come on Cathryn, hang tough. You're my living, breathing proof that romance is still alive!"

"But is it?" Cathryn questioned. "Could he still love me after all these years?"

"Do you still love him?"

Cathryn didn't have to think. "Yes, I do. Stephen is my heart."

"Well then," her friend continued, "it'll be like coming home.

'Was it possible?' Cathryn wondered. Aloud she said, "I don't know, Barbara, so much has happened over the years."

Even though Stephen married a few years after they broke up, he kept in touch with her through his yearly Christmas cards. She knew he had two beautiful daughters and a thriving business. Even if it seemed that he and his wife did not share the intense, passionate love that he had found with Cathryn, he still put a lot of energy into his marriage. He was an honorable man.

"You didn't tell me how he happened to be single again." Barbara asked.

"His wife left him for another man." Cathryn replied. "As soon as the divorce was final, he called me."

"So what does that tell you, um . . ." Barbara stopped mid-sentence as if to search her memory for something. " What did Stephen use to call you?"

"He always called me Cat."

"Well, CAT." Barbara said in an I-told-you-so tone of voice. "It may have taken 18 years, but now the man can have his children and have you, too!"

Barbara hesitated, remembering the unresolved issue of children. "What about his girls? How do you feel about them living with him?"

Cathryn replied, "You know it's funny, Barbara. I've always liked children. I just never wanted any of my own. Actually, I think I might like having kids around."

Her friend released the breath she hadn't realized she was holding and said, "Well then there's nothing to get in your way. Except maybe me. I'd better clear out before he gets here - I don't want to spoil the reunion."

"Wish me luck, Barbara."

"You won't need it;" Barbara kissed her friend good-bye, "you have love on your side."

With that, Cathryn was alone. 'He'll be here any minute now', she thought, pausing at the mirror for a final inspection. Looking again into her clear blue eyes, she knew that no matter what happened, she did not regret one day of her life. She made the right decision all those years ago, but also knew body and soul that there would never be another man for her but Stephen.

Taking a deep breath, she tried to calm herself as the buzzer rang. Heart thudding, she approached the door.

"Please God," she prayed, "let him still want me just a little."

Her heart melted when she opened the door and saw Stephen holding her favorite - a single yellow rose. Although he looked as nervous as she felt, she read determination , joy and something else on his beloved face.

"I've missed you, Cat." was all he needed to say to make the years of separation disappear.

She saw the love still shining in the warmth of his deep brown eyes and knew Barbara had been right. . . she'd come home at last.

Please rate this story
The author would appreciate your feedback.
  • COMMENTS
Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous
4 Comments
ironman1017ironman10178 months ago

Cute story, but I don’t believe she really loved him as much as she claimed. She says “since he left”; he didn’t leave she broke his heart and threw him away. Then for her to say she doesn’t regret a day in her life? If I had to go 18 years without the person I supposedly loved most in the world, I’d regret every day we couldn’t be together as that’s time we’ll never get back. Also, I bet when she’s lying in a nursing home towards the end of her life and sees all the people with children visiting and caring for them she might just, at least a little, wish she’d had kids of her own. Although maybe not. I enjoy “second chance” stories but while she claimed to love him I think he loves her more than she loves him.

AnonymousAnonymousover 9 years ago
WTF!

She threw him away for such petty reason...

I wouldn't have come back...except to say,"FUCK YOU!"

AnonymousAnonymousover 12 years ago
i like it

too bad it is too short.

Aurora BlackAurora Blackover 17 years ago
Your story

Has been mentioned in the New Story Reviews thread on the Lit forum (Author's Hangout).

Share this Story

Similar Stories

A Baby for Tina Heartbroken young widow wants a child, but gets so much more.in Romance
Kylie's Room! Pt. 01 Daddy comes home to find his daughter getting gangbanged.in NonConsent/Reluctance
The Snow Maid He sacrificed his life, and met a Goddess instead.in Sci-Fi & Fantasy
Karma is a Bitch The universe realigns.in Loving Wives
Gratitude A modest hero gets the ultimate reward for saving a life.in Group Sex
More Stories