Love Like a Blue Shell Pt. 03

*

Colin tried not to appreciate his little sister's chest, but it was definitely not little. Paige didn't have breasts or tits. This was a fucking rack - she was stacked - and Colin felt his cock grow even harder, somehow.

Paige still had her hair up in a ponytail. Her lip gloss shone perfect pink. There was this innocence about her that Colin couldn't shake. And yet her boobs were just hanging out there. Her nipples looked pencil-sharp, and her pussy was next to come out.

All Colin had to do was win. And he felt that the room was behind him. After all, Paige was the last to lose her clothes. Once everyone was naked, who knew where things would go? He looked back at Paige's perfect face. Her big brown eyes wide, almost pleading. She uncrossed her arms, shyly, to take the controller.

"Strip that sis! Strip that sis!" Even Zoe was cheering it. But Paige just looked... nervous. Colin smiled warmly.

"I've got you," he said and rubbed her arm. He was so careful not to brush Paige's massive boob, of course he ended up doing it. But she didn't seem to notice.

"It's fine," Paige said, "It's fun. I just... Not you. Not now."

Colin smiled and tousled his sister's hair. He took the first turn wrong and then ate a sand dune on the second lap. Paige might have won anyway- she drove well - but Colin made sure she did it with ease.

"Darn," he said, perhaps a bit too excitedly. Everyone groaned. They wanted Paige naked. And what kind of favor, exactly, was a sister going to force her brother to do anyway? Nothing all that exciting.

"I want a kiss," Paige said, then whispered, "a real one."

Colin paused, then bent down and put his lips on Paige's. He expected it to be dry, awkward, more than a little weird. But as their mouths touched, Colin felt a little tingle travel across his lips and explode all over his body. Shivers down his back, his arms, his legs. Paige made a little sigh, then kissed back harder. He felt his sister's tongue tease at his lips. He almost thought about letting it in, but then he stopped.

Colin looked around the room, feeling guilty and a little dazed. He expected everyone to look grossed out, but instead they all smiled and clapped.

"Nice kiss," Taylor said. Courtney cocked her eyebrow. Colin shrugged.

This was becoming a problem.

*

Once again, Tim appraised the room. Everyone was now naked, except for Paige in a pair of white panties that were rapidly turning not white. They were more than halfway through - everyone had played each other in their group once, and the standings were tight.

Tim, through some luck and (he would admit later) a little bit of practice, found himself all alone in first with three wins. Zach, Courtney, Taylor, and Paige had two wins each. Zach's, however, were from his two byes earned in the previous round. And everyone agreed that one of Paige's wins was fairly fraudulent, since her brother had taken a dive for her.

That brother, Colin, was near last with one measly win. But that was still better than Zoe who had flat zero. Bagel. Donut.

"OK, I get it," Zoe said, interrupting Tim's report. "I suck at Mario Kart. Happy?"

"I'm sure she's good at other things," Courtney said.

"You better believe it," Zach said, "Wait. Was that TMI?"

"We're all sitting in a living room naked," Zoe said, "I think TMI is AWOL. Besides, I need the ego boost."

Zoe was up against Paige and, in a bit of an upset, the tall woman won. Paige quickly shed her underwear and slinked off to the side of the room. Tim noticed the girl had a good bit of brown hair around a very pink, clean puss. Again, he reflected on how attractive Paige was, though he was pretty sure he wouldn't be enjoying any of it.

This meant the last races were down to favors. Tim imagined that, like last time, there'd be a lot more showing than sharing. He knew Courtney and Taylor would want to do some stuff. And Paige was unattached so chances were good that she'd be more willing to play around.

Zoe was a bit of a mystery, though. At times, she almost seemed to be enjoying herself. Would she take the opportunity to have some illicit enjoyment? Would Zach let it go that far? That was the other unknown, how far would everyone's significant others be willing to take things?

Zach and Zoe had seemed pretty distant from each other the whole game. But if it got serious, would Zach be willing to give and take? Colin had been pretty loose with things last time, but how would he feel if his girlfriend gave it to something other than a pillow? And while Tim was more than happy for Taylor to fool around - found that he enjoyed it actually - he had to wonder about his own limits. How far was too far? Tim kept looking for road signs and saw nothing but horizon.

Tim was up against Colin next, and so one of them would be doing something to someone. With the win, Tim could basically seal his way to the finals. He wouldn't be completely uncatchable, but it was close enough. He started to think about how he'd play it out if he won. Who he wanted to pair with. Who he'd want for himself. Surprisingly, he found himself thinking about Zoe.

With his mind racing about other things, Tim lost the race. Maybe this was the lack of 'killer instinct' that Taylor was always complaining about. He hoped Colin would be generous with his punishment.

Colin spent a good amount of time looking from girl to girl. Then finally he shrugged and pointed to Zoe. "Show her." Zoe looked confused, but Tim just shrugged. He grabbed her hand and lead her back to his bedroom.

"Three minutes!" Taylor called after them, "Not to completion."

"Tim'll probably go twice in that time," Zach said and snickered.

"And how, exactly, would you know that, hm?" Courtney asked. Zach stopped laughing.

*

Back in the bedroom, Tim turned down the light a little and then climbed up on the bed. Zoe sat across from him. She really was quite attractive, Tim thought to himself. It was just she was busy frowning all the time so it was hard to notice.

"If this is to show me your comic book collection..."

"Fuck, Zoe, why do you have to be such a bitch all the time?" Tim said, the words tumbling out of him all at once, "You seem like a great girl. Really smart and super attractive. I don't know why you feel the need to be so... awful."

Tim hadn't intended to say any of it. He sat back, almost shocked at himself. Braced for the blowback.

Zoe, though, didn't do anything. They just sat there in silence. Finally, Zoe put her head down and sighed. Spoke to the bedspread "I'm sorry. I'm just in a crappy mood. I wasn't expecting all this. With everyone and Zach. And you."

"You've seemed OK to me. Even caught you smiling a few times."

"I know. I really am having fun. Only I don't think I'm supposed to be having fun and it's got me twisted up inside."

"I know exactly what you mean," Tim said.

"OK, so what do you have to show me?"

Tim reached down and took his cock in hand. The argument with Zoe had shrunk him up some, but seeing her now was enough. Her breasts hung tantalizingly just an arm's length away. Her legs hung open, so comfortable showing her snatch. Tim started to slowly stroke.

"Oh," Zoe said, suddenly watching him intently, "Oh my."

Tim just kind of tilted his head. He took his time. Savored.

"Should I...?" Zoe asked and sort of reached down at her snatch.

"He said 'show her.' He didn't say anything about showing me."

"Oh. OK," Zoe seemed almost disappointed. "You, ummmm, you have a nice cock. Really thick."

"That's time guys!" Taylor called from the living room. Tim hadn't gotten into much of a rhythm so it was easy enough just to stop. He took Zoe's hand and was surprised when she squeezed him back. It made him want to be brave one more time.

"It seems to me that we have plenty of time to be old," he said as they started to walk out of the room together, "The rest of our lives, really. So why not stay young for as long as you can?"

Zoe nodded. "Yeah - I'm starting to see that."

*

When they came back, everyone teased Tim and Zoe about what might have just happened in the bedroom. Taylor could tell that they hadn't done much. She decided, once again, she should try to push things forward a bit more. After all, how could you get anywhere if you only stood still?

Taylor's next race was another wild card. The luck gods selected Paige, which was a tough matchup. Still, Taylor could tell that Colin's little sister wasn't taking her as seriously as she should. Paige was still expecting round 1 Taylor, and not the new, dangerous playing-to-win Taylor. I really need to thank Sydney, Taylor thought to herself.

After Taylor took the win, Paige seemed disappointed, but not too disappointed. As the only single girl there, Taylor knew the cute coed had to be thinking about having a little fun. Now it was just a matter of picking who to pair her with.

Obviously, all kissing aside, Taylor couldn't put Paige with her older brother. That meant Zach or Tim and that was an easy choice. What kind of girlfriend would she be if she didn't throw a hot piece of college ass Tim's way every now and again?

"Teach him," Taylor said, pointing at Tim. Both newly partnered players looked confused.

"Look guys," Zoe said. "We're all naked, we're all fooling around. Speaking in code like this is just dumb." Zoe of all people! You could have knocked Taylor over with a flaccid dick.

"It's immature," Colin said.

"Agreed," Zoe said. "Just say what you want. No one is going to judge you. Trust me. Taylor, if you want Tim to stuff a lubed-up banana in Paige's ass and then play the banjo while she sucks him off then just say so."

"That isn't what you want is it?" Tim asked.

"No," Taylor said, "But it's a good idea for the next round. Paige, show Tim how you get off, then have him do it for you."

"To, ummm, completion?" Paige asked. Zoe made a low exasperated sigh.

"You've got five minutes," Taylor said, "Whatever you can accomplish in that time is fine by me. So if you want to get off, better teach him quick."

Paige grunted, grabbed Tim's hand, and dragged him back to the bedroom once again.

"You guys are really going to need new sheets," Zach said.

"Whole bedroom set," Taylor said, "Supposed to be delivered on Thursday."

*

Tim climbed back on the bed. Paige sort of flopped down next to him. He felt a bit of deja vu - only it was a different girl. Still he wondered if the same forthrightness might help him forward.

"Paige, I'm sorry," Tim said, "I don't really know you all that well, but I feel like we got off on the wrong foot. If you just want to sit here and glare at me for five minutes, that's fine. I'll tell the others I was too stupid to figure it out, or whatever."

"What? No, you're fine," Paige said, "Look, the timer is already running. This has been a whole lot of build up for not much action and my pussy is fucking aching. So if you don't mind?"

"Oh," Tim said, "Sorry."

The pretty young brunette spread her legs and dipped a finger into her hole. She slowly rubbed it in and out while she teased her clit with her free hand. Paige kept slowly rubbing, talking like she was doing a cooking demonstration while she warmed up her tight, little oven. "Put a finger in me to start. Just one. Then with your other hand sort of rub around until you find my clit."

This was Colin's innocent little sister? Tim had watched porn that was less explicit.

"Seriously, get to it," Paige said. Tim did as he was told and put his pointer in Paige's snatch while he felt around for her magic button. The little bundle of nerve endings wasn't hard to find, it practically leapt into his palm. Paige gave a long loud sigh.

"There you go. Now just swirl that back and forth. Lightly! That's it. Very slowly, put a second finger in me..."

Paige reached down and lifted her breast. It was big enough that she could kind of lick at the engorged nipple.

"Want me to do that?" Tim asked.

"Whatever floats your boat," Paige said. Tim took her breast into his mouth and it was glorious. So round and full. He desperately wanted to caress it with his hands, but they were a little busy at the moment.

"Faster," he heard Paige say. "Harder."

Tim pressed down on her clit and started really rubbing now. He knew Taylor liked a side-to-side motion and so he did the same to Paige. She didn't complain. He sawed his two fingers in and out of her. The coed was so tight, he thought that it might be better just to go back to a single digit.

Paige started making little noises now, in time with Tim's movements. It was so hot, seeing this pretty girl get off - even hotter that he was the one doing it to her. Her ponytail swished back and forth. Her pink, glossy lips squeezed shut. Big brown eyes open. Searching.

Paige's whole body began to buck. Her legs and thighs kicking out. Tim felt her body begin to tremble and then...

TIME

"That's time guys!" Taylor called out. Tim would have been willing to continue - seriously, what was Taylor going to do? - but Paige slipped off the bed and stood. She gave Tim a little kiss on the cheek, and then the two of them went back to the living room.

Paige's older brother was standing there staring expectantly. Colin hadn't looked this upset when Tim had been doing all kinds of stuff with his wife, Tim thought. But he seemed nervous now. Anxious. Even a little angry? God, Tim hoped not. What had Taylor gotten him into?

"He was a perfect gentleman," Paige said, then kissed her brother lightly on the cheek. That seemed to settle Colin down and they started the next race.

*

"I'm tired of Tim getting all the action," Colin said. Zach agreed.

"Good thing I'm racing Courtney next," Zach said. Colin practically froze in place.

"I mean, ummm..." Zach said, "Fuck. I'm sorry, man. That's not what I meant."

"It's cool," Colin said. First Tim with his sister then Zach with his wife. Even if Courtney won, she might... Colin sighed. This is fun, he told himself. He looked over at Taylor - naked, sexy Taylor with the tight body and the great tits. Oh yeah he felt far better about everything now.

Colin glanced over at his sister. Paige had come back looking a little flushed and for a moment Colin had pictured himself in the bedroom watching Paige's breasts shake back and forth while he stroked his sister to...

OK, maybe he was feeling a little too much better.

Colin looked up at the race and saw that Courtney had won. Zach had been unstoppable for the first round, but now he couldn't seem to get going. What had happened?

Courtney eyed Zach. With their different heights, his penis was practically level with her stomach. Finally she just grabbed his hand and dragged him forward, "Come on," she said.

"What's the favor?" Taylor asked.

"Just set the timer for five minutes!" Courtney said.

"Well, OK then," Taylor said.

Well this was something new, and it didn't make Colin feel very good about things. He'd accepted that Courtney wanted to fool around. Had even come to enjoy his own little extramarital adventures.

But this felt different somehow. She was going off to another room to do who knows what and it...

"Wait," Colin said. The whole room froze in place, Courtney and Zach already halfway down the hallway. "I just, ummm, maybe you should stay out here."

"Everybody has done stuff," Taylor said, "You can't just..."

"No, no," Colin said, "Of course she and Zach should still do whatever they were going to do. But if it's out here then everybody, y'know, knows what's going on." Yes, that made much more sense, he thought. My friend should totally fool around with my wife - I just want to watch it happen! God this was a weird world he was now living in.

"That's fair," Zoe said, "I could see wondering about what actually went on."

"I don't know," Courtney said, "Won't it be weird, like, watching?"

"To me it's actually a lot more fun this way," Paige said.

"We all did it in front of each other last time," Taylor said, "And Courtney, didn't you tell me you wanted to see more?"

Courtney sighed, clearly defeated. "OK. I want to y'know. While he... Y'know."

"God dammit," Zoe said, "I thought we talked about this."

"Right," Courtney said, clearly thrown off by all these new events, "Sorry. I want to rub myself off while Zach rubs himself."

"I'll give you three minutes for that," Taylor said.

"I don't think that's enough time for me to..." Courtney stopped herself. "Three minutes is fine."

Taylor set the time on her watch. Tim tossed Courtney a pillow, but she pushed it away. "I've been practicing the other way," she said.

Courtney sat down on the floor with Zach across from her. They both took themselves in hand and started working. Colin didn't really want to focus on what his wife was doing. But then he didn't want to watch Zach, either.

Almost immediately, Colin heard Zach's breath begin to catch. Courtney mewled and gasped. They were both getting close. No doubt urging each other on.

Except for the one time at the party, when everyone had been so worked up that it hardly mattered, the couples had managed to keep their moment of ecstasy private. Colin thought it was better this way. Courtney's orgasm, unique to her, ought to be his and his alone. Zach shouldn't know how Courtney's whole body would tense when he reached her apex. The way she'd gasp - like holding her breath - and turn bright red.

But Courtney certainly seemed on her way to sharing when, finally, the timer went off. Taylor's phone sang a happy little jingle that seemed almost mocking in the context of what they'd been doing.

Courtney gave a big sigh and reluctantly dragged her hand away from her dripping pussy. Zach leaned back, eyes closed, like searching for the serenity to go on.

"How was that?" Zach asked.

"Fun," Courtney said, "I think I prefer the pillow, though."

*

With two races to go, Taylor, Tim and Courtney shared the lead with three wins each. Everyone else was tied at two, except for poor Zoe who might as well have retired from racing right then.

Zach looked really agitated from his previous punishment. He was pacing back and forth, his long thin penis extended out like a rapier. Now that she was sure that Zach was truly, fully engorged, Taylor was positive he had the longest penis in the apartment (though a good bit thinner than Tim's thick tool). She started to wonder what it might feel like inside her.

Well, the sexy brunette was certain she wouldn't get to experience that. But she decided to help poor Zach out in other ways. He was her opponent for the next race, so that made things pretty easy.

For a moment, Taylor considered letting Zach take the win and see if he'd take her. But she decided that winning the big game was more important. She could have whatever she wanted if she won. Instead, Taylor destroyed him on the track.

She was well into her victory lap before Zach even finished. He tossed the controller down and made a pained noise. He'd clearly planned on taking care of things if he'd won, and Taylor felt a twinge of regret at not letting him. But not for long.

"It's OK," she told him, "I've got you."

Taylor stood in the center of the room and gestured for Zach to stand, too. He looked up at her warily, then limped over. Taylor figured the poor boy's balls had to be blue as marbles by this point.

"Just come over here," Taylor said and grabbed him by the cock, pulling him forward. If Zoe had any complaint, Taylor didn't hear it. She just glorified in how Zach's cock felt in her hand. Warm and strong yet soft to the touch.

"Holy fuck," Paige said.

"Hell if that's a loss, I'll never win again," Colin said.