Senior Year Memories Ch. 10

There was a battle going on behind Sophie's eyes, mental torment between what she wanted to do and what she'd been told to do all her life. It appeared a pretty vicious battle, but one that we might've been winning the way she panted.

"Y... yes..." Sophie said softly, looking deeply into my eyes, her breathing ragged for what Josie was doing to her pussy.

"Then, right now, what do you want to do?" Josie asked her.

Biting her lip, Sophie first looked from Josie, then to me, then leaned in and kissed me. It was her first kiss, more excited than skilled, but since I couldn't have been any better my first time, I didn't hold it against her. I did make out with her, trying to start her off slow. Her lips were soft and delectable, and after a few moments like this she caught onto my pace. Though she was still raw, she was catching on quickly, which boded well for whatever else we'd wind up doing.

Then she reached for my cock with one of her dainty hands, touching it slightly, then wrapping her hand experimentally around the head. Curious, she rolled her palm over the precum and spread it across the head, inexpertly jacking my cock in a way that didn't feel all that bad. She needed some practice, but she was definitely a natural. Either that, or she took in more of the porn than I'd thought.

Josie was kissing her neck, and I'd started getting my hands in on the act, squeezing at Sophie's tits, occasionally reaching around her to do the same to Josie. Eventually, I settled on moving one of my hands between Sophie's thighs, pulling up her skirt and replacing Josie's hand with mine, gently running circles over Sophie's pussy through her panties. They were nearly soaked through, and with her skirt up I could smell the rich scent of her cunt. I wanted more, so I pushed her panties to the side, running my fingers up and down the hot, wet folds of her pussy. Sophie moaned as I curled my fingers around her pussy, slipping my index and forefinger into her unbelievably tight lips while running circles over her engorged clit with my thumb.

"What is that? What is that? What, oh my goodness, what's happening? What's happening?" Sophie asked.

"Relax, you're gonna cum, just let it happen, let it happen," Josie said, pulling Sophie close to her, squeezing her tits and licking her ear.

"I'm gonna cum?" Sophie asked me, almost looking concerned.

"Trust me, you're gonna love it," I said.

Sophie bit her lip. "I don't know, I don't know, I've never, I've never, oh my goodness, oh my good- OH MY FUCK!"

Sophie screamed loudly, bucking and shaking against both me and Josie. Thank god she let go of my cock and started grabbing the bed sheets instead, since I'm pretty sure she'd have ripped my cock off with that kind of force. More than anything else, I was worried someone outside might've heard us. Josie must've been on the same wavelength, but she had the novel solution of deeply kissing Sophie. Her scream was cut off, replaced by a high whimper as she made out with Josie and came down from her very first cum.

It took forever, but finally Sophie's orgasm calmed, her bucking slowing, her eyes lidding over as a look of great contentment crossed her face. Josie and her making out was no longer an act of desperation but one of great need. Their kissing slowed, and after a few gentle kisses that spread some of Josie's black lipstick across her lips, Sophie parted.

After an orgasm as powerful as the one she just had, I'd have thought she'd have been smiling, but it didn't take her long to come back to earth and come back hard. Her eyes went wide, and she looked at Josie and me with a look that might've been fear.

"I shouldn't have... this was... this was wrong," Sophie said, trying to gather herself up. She ran her fingers over her lips, the swell of her breasts, even down to her thighs. Once her fingers found those, though, they darted away as if they touched something electrified. She rubbed her hands compulsively on the bed sheets, trying to rub away all the precum from her inexpert jacking of my cock.

"It seemed pretty fucking right to me for how hard you came," Josie said.

Sophie bit her lip, her fingers finally taking hold of the gold cross around her neck. Her eyes darted back and forth between us, frantic. "This was sinful, what we did, we can't... you can't tell anyone, you can't-"

"Have you been listening to us? We don't want to tell anyone. We didn't come here to blackmail you, we just wanted to talk, and this, well, it sort of happened," I said. I couldn't help but notice that she wouldn't look me in the eyes, but couldn't take her eyes off of my cock. For her fear, she was breathing heavily, looking at it with eyes that held a mix of confusion and a hungry lust I'd become very familiar with.

"It's pretty great, isn't it?" Josie whispered in her ear. Sophie flinched at her words, but still couldn't take her eyes from my cock. For the attention, I was sure my cock had never been harder.

"I shouldn't be here. I shouldn't be looking at this. I shouldn't..." Sophie trailed off.

Josie answered her. "Don't think about what other people tell you you should and shouldn't do. Don't let anybody control you but you. You look at that cock right now, you look at it long and hard, and you tell me what you want to do with it, because I'll tell you, if you get that in you, it's even better than it looks."

Sophie didn't move to do anything, either leaning toward my cock or making to leave. I wanted her to touch it. I wanted her to do more to it really, but I wasn't going to push her, not with her head like this. Thankfully, for all of us, Josie was pretty damn convincing.

"Say it, right now. Tell us what you wanna do with that cock," Josie said.

"I want to taste it," Sophie whispered, licking her lips.

"Then what's stopping you?" Josie asked.

Sophie leaned over, her face inches away from my cock, eying it reverently. She reached out slowly, trying to wrap her hand around the base of my cock and finding her fingers couldn't reach each other. I shuddered at her soft touch, the feeling of her breath on the tip of my cock. She'd gotten me worked up earlier, but her momentary rejection had slowed me. Now that she was back, staring at my cock, I realized how sensitive she'd gotten me.

Tentatively she stuck out her tongue, licking the bottom of my cockhead, tasting the slightest hint of my precum. I shivered. So did she, for that matter. Josie herself egged her on, pressing Sophie forward. Sophie ran her tongue all over the head, licking up as much of the precum as she could, moaning softly at the taste. Her tongue was electric against me and it took all I could not to grab her and facefuck her into oblivion right there, but thankfully she wanted more than just a taste. Much more. She parted her plump lips in anticipation, reaching the head of my cock and wrapping them around it. Even opening as wide as she could, she could barely get the head in without some difficulty, but Josie's insistent pressure on the back of her neck and whispered advice on how to relax certainly helped. Sophie couldn't down all of my ten inches, she wasn't that good yet, but she was eager enough to get me to the back of her throat. She choked, maybe even gagged, but soon she was bobbing up and down on my cock. Like her handjob, it was fast and inexpert, but she knew enough not to use her teeth, and her enthusiasm mixed together with her lips felt damn good.

While Sophie gave me her first ever blowjob, Josie kept busy behind her, guiding her, coaxing her onto her knees on the bed. Now sucking me off while on knees, her ass sticking up in the air and her tits pillowing beneath her arms, Sophie barely noticed as Josie pulled her conservative skirt and plain white panties down over her magnificent ass. Sophie barely noticed when Josie took a long, loving look at her bare, pale and enormous yet tight ass, cocking a glance my way and mouthing 'wow!' while Sophie still went down on me. It was impossible, from this angle, for Sophie to notice Josie pulling off first her coat, then her tight black leather top, exposing her beautifully pale D-cup tits to the world. I'd become intimately familiar with topless Josie, from her pointed brown nipples to the piercing through her left nip to the number of tattoos she loved to hide and share in equal measure, and yet still I found it easy to be in awe of Josie's hot body.

What Sophie couldn't help but notice, however, was Josie burying her face in her pussy. Sophie's eyes shot open in surprise and she moaned lustfully around my cock as Josie ate her pussy. She nearly let up, nearly pulled off my cock, but I was so close I just grabbed her by the hair and continued fucking into her face.

Sophie's eyes were wide, almost rolling back into her head from the pleasure as she sucked my cock while Josie ate her out. It was far from the best blowjob I'd ever had, but with Sophie so hot and it being her first, I wasn't complaining.

Sophie's moans became a high-pitched wail when Josie pushed two of her fingers into her pussy. When Josie pushed another finger into her asshole, however, Sophie went off with yet another powerful orgasm.

"Oh fuck, oh fuck, OH FUCK!" I roared as her orgasm set me off, cumming deep into her mouth, down her throat. Though taken off guard at first, Sophie made a good effort to swallow my cum down, but the flow was just too much, too hard, and she couldn't take it all. She came up for air, my cock still shooting rope after rope of cum all over her face, neck and the sweater stretched across her massive rack. A large drop even splattered against the hanging gold cross on her necklace, which made it glint a different color briefly in the low light of the room.

Wobbily, Sophie pushed herself up onto her knees, looking down at the mess I made all over her and taking one last gulp of the cum still left in her mouth. On her knees, I could finally see the dark thatch of her rather hairy bush peeking out from beneath her sweater.

"Wow," she said.

"I know, pretty cool, right?" Josie replied.

Still looking down at herself in awe, Sophie repeated, "Wow."

"I think we may have finally made her speechless," I said, laughing as I came down from my own orgasm.

"So, how would you rate your first facial?" Josie asked, crawling up behind Sophie and wrapping her arms around Sophie's chest, palming the underside of her tits.

"I didn't expect to like it, but... that tasted really good," Sophie said, smiling as if she were fit to blush.

Leaning over Sophie's shoulder, Josie licked some of my cum off her cheek. "I won't say that every guy's as delicious as Ryan here, but I think we might be able to make a true cumslut of you yet."

For a moment, Sophie looked conflicted, but when Josie went from licking my cum from her face to making out with Sophie again, all that conflict disappeared.

Watching the two of them make out was undeniably one of the hottest things I'd ever seen, and I'd seen some pretty fucking hot things these past couple months. I'd have been fine just sitting there watching them, but that wasn't enough. I wanted in on this. I crawled over to them, pulling at the base of Sophie's sweater and blouse. Sophie didn't resist as I pulled the soiled garment over her head and tossed it aside.

"Holy fucking shit," I said as I finally got a look at her bra-clad tits. Her tits were every bit as massive as I'd thought, perhaps an easy F-cup, but even at that size they were still threatening to burst from her bra. Relieving the pressure, Josie undid Sophie's bra from behind, tossing it aside with the rest and leaving Sophie, save for her little gold cross, nude between us. Her nipples were large and flat, about the size of the palm of my hand, but the little nubs that stuck out were hard and proud.

Josie craned her neck around Sophie. "Holy fucking shit is right; have you ever seen tits this huge?"

I could've answered honestly and told them about the time I tittyfucked Haley Campbell's H-cup tits, but feeling diplomatic, I just repeated, "Holy fucking shit."

Josie pushed Sophie squealing onto her back on the bed, licking the last of the cum from her face and neck while she took off her own short leather skirt and panties. Now left only in her fishnets and heavy black boots, Josie laid beside Sophie so she could suck on her massive tits.

Sophie looked up at me, eyes lidded over in pleasure and cracking a smile that actually had some good humor to it. "You're overdressed."

"Ah, good point," I said. I jumped off the bed and stripped down as quickly as I could, sliding back onto the bed beside them so I could latch my lips around the nipple that Josie wasn't monopolizing. We laid there for a while, Josie and me, each sucking on one of Sophie's nipples and watching her face contort with ecstasy. It was still strange trying to wrap my head around all that'd happened, since less than an hour ago I was viewing Sophie as someone close to an enemy, but the way things had been going lately, I was just rolling with it.

"So," Josie said, getting up on her knees and crawling over to Sophie's head. "I think we can all agree that I just made you cum pretty fucking good, right?"

"It was pretty nice," Sophie admitted.

"Good," Josie said, throwing one leg over Sophie's head, straddling her face. "Then seein' as how I'm the only one here who hasn't cum yet, I figure you owe me a favor."

Josie settled her weight down, fully sitting on Sophie's face. In surprise, Sophie struggled beneath her as Josie pressed her pussy to her mouth, but Josie didn't let up.

"Oh, come on, it's not any worse than anything else we've done, and besides, I'm staying here until you eat my pussy and make me fucking cum all over that sweet little face of yours," Josie said, reaching down and idly playing with Sophie's cross, then her tits. I couldn't see Sophie's face for being crushed beneath Josie's marvelous pussy, but the way Josie began to moan I knew that Sophie was giving it her best.

"Hey, Ryan, why don't you help motivate Sophie? Show her what a real pussy-licking's like?" Josie suggested.

"Not a bad idea," I said, sliding between Sophie's legs and wrapping my mouth around her delicious pussy, pushing two fingers inside to aid my efforts. Fuck, she was tight. Maybe too tight, I feared. I knew she was a virgin, and I knew I wanted to fuck her, but I didn't want to fuck anything up.

At least I wasn't fucking anything up yet, not by the way her hips writhed against my face.

"She's got a tasty little virgin pussy, doesn't she?" Josie said, moaning appreciatively at however Sophie had picked up her pace.

"Nice and sweet," I confirmed, running my tongue over the engorged nub of her clitoris, pulling a deep moan from Sophie.

With both my and Sophie's mouths occupied, Josie kept the foulness flowing from between her black-painted lips, smeared from her eating Sophie out earlier. "Did you ever think you'd be getting it on with an Asian goth slut and a nerd in the back of your fucking church? Oh, yes, my, my, my, you are a nasty little slut. You say you're all about the purity, but you're thinking about cock and pussy and fucking all the time, aren't you? All you uptight girls really are like that deep down, dirty fucking cumsluts just waiting to come out? Say it! Say it or I'll tell Ryan not to let you cum!"

She cocked her head at me that actually said she would do no such thing (Josie may have been dark, but she was no monster), but Sophie couldn't see that. "Yes, yes, I'm a dirty fucking cumslut!"

"You want this, don't you?" Josie taunted.

"So bad," Sophie moaned as I twisted my fingers around in her deeper, sucking harder on her clit.

Josie dropped back down on her face, moaning and gyrating her hips and pinching her nipples. She flicked her piercing, moaning loudly as she rocked against Sophie's face. Watching her up there, in complete lewd command of Sophie, was unquestionably one of the hottest things I'd ever seen. Josie's eyes bored down into mine, her face a mask of pure confidence and lust. I'd had a lot of connections with a lot of girls lately, but the energy that passed between me and Josie was something unique. It was weird to be reminded of this when both of us were connected to another girl, but there was a silent, emotional understanding that I think passed between us then and there.

I began to understand, then and there, that Josie and I were probably going to have to have a conversation soon.

Until then, we still had Sophie.

"Come on, Sophie, come on you tight fucking little slut, cum for us, set me fucking off, make me fucking cum in your fucking HELL HOUSE YOU CUMSLUT BITCH, FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCK!!" Josie cried out as she came, her juices splashing down Sophie's neck as she too came in my mouth. I lapped up her juices eagerly, almost as eager as she was for me to keep going the way her legs tightened around my neck.

The two moaning, twitching girls collapsed onto the bed beside each other, breathing heavily and panting and looking about as hot as I think as it was physically possible to look. Not wanting to be left out and with a cock that was every bit as hard as it had ever been, I crawled up between them, wrapping an arm around each of their shoulders and feeling like a fucking king as I alternated between kissing each of them.

They could've spent as long as they wanted catching their breaths as far as I was concerned, but Sophie had a different idea. Hesitantly, she reached down and began stroking my precum slick cock with her light, delicate hand. I shivered at her touch, planting a deep kiss on her lips.

She looked up into my eyes, smiling nervously. "All my life, I've been told that lust was a great sin, and that keeping my purity was perhaps my greatest gift. They always told me I had to keep it for God or keep it for my husband, like it was something that didn't belong to me."

Neither Josie nor I said anything, letting Sophie come to what must have been a truly difficult speech to put together. Perhaps sensing our understanding, Sophie smiled a bit wider, the rolled over so she could straddle my hips, her absolutely titanic tits hanging down like the ripest imaginable fruit. Her slick, hairy cunt ground against my cock, driving me wild.

"There's a lot I need to pray on after what you two have done for me here tonight, a lot I need to ask of my soul and my God, but there is one conclusion I've come to," she said.

"What's that?" I asked.

Sophie pulled off her purity ring and tossed it aside. "Purity is overrated."

Reaching down, she guided the head of my cock toward her insanely tight pussy lips. Even from the outside, her pussy was tight, and I wasn't sure that I'd fit. Even if I did fit, I didn't want to hurt her, but if I was worried, she was determined. Biting her lip, she pushed down against my cockhead, forcing it to part her lips, then popping the head inside. She was almost painfully tight, but thank god we'd made her cum so many times first if just for the lubrication, as it helped me slide inside.

"Oh my, oh my, oh my FUCK, FUCK, FUCK, IT'S STRETCHING ME, TEARING ME APART, SO FUCKING GOOD, FUCK, FUCK, FUCK!" Sophie squeaked as she sat on my cock, spearing herself on it an inch at a time. From the side, I caught a flash as Josie immortalized this moment with my phone's camera in what I was sure would be a pretty fucking awesome picture.

Inch by agonizing inch, she pressed my cock into her tight cunt. I watched as half of it disappeared into her, then three quarters. Finally content that she had must've had it, she dropped her entire weight on me, burying the entirety of my cock in her pussy. Her eyes wide with surprise, pain, pleasure, I don't know, she looked down the valley of her immense cleavage, past the gold, cum-smeared cross that hung between her tits, to my cock buried in her pussy.