Senior Year Memories Ch. 10

"It's so, wow, so big," Sophie said, in awe at the vulgar display between her legs.

"Thanks," I said.

"Congratulations on no longer being a virgin. Sorry I didn't bring you a card and some balloons," Josie joked.

Sophie ignored her, still entranced with my cock in her pussy.

"I can... I can feel you, all the way inside of me. It hurts, some, but it feels good, too. I think it might feel real good," Sophie said, running her hands along my less than impressive abs, still in awe.

"You think that's great, you should try moving," Josie suggested.

"I was working up to it," Sophie said. "I just, I want to feel this, let it all sink in. It's kind of a monumental sort of occasion, wouldn't you say? I wanted to give it the proper weight."

"Give it all the weight you want. I'm fine here," I said. I said this, but only because it felt like the slightest motion from her might set me off for how tight she was, and I wanted to make her first fuck memorable.

Slowly, she started to move experimentally, first rocking her hips a little, then pushing herself up and down on my cock. Only an inch or two at a time at first, but with Josie's gentle coaxing, her hands pressing against Sophie's stomach and ass, guiding her onward and helping her develop a pleasurable rhythm. Sophie was a quick study, not quite a natural, but pretty close to one. Little by little, she began to take more and more of my cock with each bounce, settling on a slow but increasing pace where she took nearly half of my length at a go. Her speed increasing, her face lost its consternation and got a look of tentative pleasure to it, a look I liked seeing spread across her lips.

Moaning with pleasure, she started to fuck down onto me in earnest, no longer needing Josie's guidance. Seeing that she was no longer needed (and because she loved to watch), Josie rolled beside us, furiously fingering her own pussy with one hand while her other drifted into one of mine. She held my hand tightly as I began fucking up into Sophie in earnest, and though I wanted to give her due attention, it was hard not looking into Josie's makeup streaked eyes, seeing the excitement and promise that danced within her dark brown orbs, knowing that something special was happening that night.

Squeezing my hand once more, she let go and set both of her hands to her pussy, letting me turn my full attention to fucking Sophie.

Josie's timing couldn't have been better, because Sophie was starting to understand the pace of a truly furious fuck, bouncing down on me with an increasing speed that sent her titanic tits colliding into each other.

"Fuck, fuck, fuck this is great, I never knew, I should've known, should've never believed, fuck, it's good, amazing, FUCK, FUCK, FUCK ME, RYAN! FUCK MY SLUTTY CUNT!!" Sophie roared.

I grabbed her tits, squeezing them, hoping to keep them from colliding at the pace she'd established, but there was no way they'd be constrained. Instead I settled on grabbing her ass, helping her fuck down onto me as I pushed into her.

Building up to a release, I grabbed her by the hips and rolled over so I was on top of her. She looked up at me in surprise, but her smile was one of the cutest, sweetest I'd ever seen, especially when I took over and began to pound down into her.

"So, I take it you're having fun?" I grunted as I fucked down into her.

"Yes, yes, yes," she moaned. "I wanna fuck, all the time, this is so, amazing!"

I kissed her, making out with her passionately as my hips became a pounding blur. I was gonna cum, I just hoped that she'd go off first.

On that, I was wrong. Josie came first, moaning loudly as she bucked against her own fingers. Sophie wasn't far behind, cumming beneath me one final, loud time. With seconds to spare, I pulled out of her and fired shot after shot of cum across her stomach, tits, even some splashing onto her neck and chin, before I once again rolled onto my back between her and Josie.

"Holy fuck. That... that was incredible," Sophie moaned.

"Wait'll you have that cock in your ass," Josie replied, leaning over to lick some of my cum off of Sophie's tits.

Sophie considered what she had to say. "I don't... I'll need to think about that."

"Do that. Getting ass-fucked is so much more intense than you could possibly imagine, and Ryan's pretty fucking good at ass-fucking," Josie said.

"Awww, thank you," I said, unable in my exhaustion to meet her eyes.

"Wow," Sophie said, thinking on her words.

Remembering what we'd come here for, I decided to ask, "So, I'm sure it probably goes without saying at this point, but are we good on the whole Halloween thing?"

"You're fine," Sophie replied. "No protest, and you don't need to do an article or anything to placate me. I'll keep the Brigade here running the Hell House."

"Sweet," Josie said.

"Thanks," I replied. With what little energy I had left, I crawled up to her and planted a kiss on her lips. She giggled, softly.

"I... I will see one or both of you again sometime, right?" Sophie asked.

Unhesitatingly, Josie replied, "Count on it."

***

While Sophie debated just how in the hell she was going to clean up the mess we'd made, Josie and I got dressed and snuck back to her car, unseen by anyone we ought to have been worried about. It was a minor blessing, but once we got to her car and drove off, we broke down laughing.

"So, we saved Halloween," Josie said.

"Nadia will be so proud of us," I replied.

"Everyone will be," Josie said.

"Too bad we can't tell them how it happened. No one would believe us," I said.

"Why does that mean we can't spread it around?" Josie asked as we stopped at a red light.

That... that was a good question. Two months ago, I'd have never thought about talking about things like this, but two months ago I didn't understand how Regan Hills High truly worked. I didn't understand the depths of depravity that most students lived in, and how well I'd fit in as a part of it.

"Hey, Ryan?"

Lost in thought, I hadn't even noticed that Josie was looking at me. I did notice when she bent over and kissed me on the lips. It was a soft, lingering kiss, the kind I could've gotten lost and stayed lost in for a while. When we parted, she smiled at me with a perfectly sweet contentment.

"You know what I really want right now?" she asked, getting moving once the light turned green.

"What's that?" I asked.

"I wanna find a good frozen yogurt place that's still open, preferably someplace with a lot of toppings. I want some quality fro-yo with a lot of toppings, then I want to go someplace quiet where I can tittyfuck you back to hardness so you can buttfuck me like crazy. That sound good to you?" Josie asked, her voice never losing any of that sweetness.

Smiling, I replied, "Sounds perfect."

"I thought so," Josie replied.

***

Author's Note 2: The Second One: Yes, we've finally made it to Halloween! Being one of my favorite times of year, Halloween is going to be split into two chapters to cover both the events of day and night. While night is going to be full of tricks and surprises, for the day portion I'm looking to bring back some favorite returning girls for some Halloween fun. However, since you have all been amazing, I wanted to give you a bit of say in this. If there's a girl you'd like to see featured again, please drop her into a review or in feedback, and I'll feature the most popular one I get. This is an experiment I hope doesn't explode on me, but is my way of saying thank you to you all for the encouragement. I'll give this a little time before I start writing the chapter, but once I do I'll inform you all in the reviews.