Extra Credit Pt. 04

"Please," she huffed. "Eden, may I cum?" Again the sound of my first name aroused me. I had restricted Cayla from using it unless she was on the verge of an orgasm.

"No, Cayla. You're going to have to wait." She gritted her teeth as I returned to her wet hole and pressed the vibrator back into her, this time further. I needed to apply more pressure to get it to move inside of her but I assumed from her lip biting and humming that what she was experiencing was an even exchange of pain and pleasure.

"Ahhh," She whimpered as the vibrator made it half way inside of her. I twisted the cap at the bottom of the toy and the vibrations instantly doubled to a higher speed. Cayla twitched while a new pitch of moaning broke through the room. Her hands tied behind her back were balled up into fists, knuckles white.

"Good girl," I cooed. If I was hurting her she did a phenomenal job of bottling it up, but I doubted that was the case. I moved the toy into her at a slow pace, pulling out whenever I felt her inner walls resisting it. With this rhythm I began to notice myself stretching her enough to reach a little further each time. I continued to pay her clit close attention, as she was very responsive to the treatment and I wanted her to enjoy this as much as I did. I had actually penetrated her and it was better than anything I had conjured throughout the day.

"Eden, I need to cum. Please, can I cum?" Her voice was quickened now and I could only imagine what she had to do to hold herself back from releasing. I laughed softly behind her as I began to pump the vibrator in and out of her.

"No, Cayla. Not yet."

"Please!" She cried desperately. At her begging I removed the vibrator and swung my open palm across her left butt cheek. Slap. Cayla inhaled hard and held her breath in shock.

"I said no," I clarified. She remained silent, the only sound in the room being the electronic buzz of the toy in my hand.

"I don't like you talking back to me after I've given you a command." I rose to my feet and shut the vibrator off.

"I'm sorry, Miss Vega," Cay said softly, once more reliant on her hearing as I pulled away from her. I moved towards the closet and shuffled through the bags with a new idea in mind.

"Yes, well I think I've been spoiling you too much. I was going to let you cum before your punishment but I think this way will help you learn a lesson." Behind me I heard her sigh with frustration as she realized her release would not come soon.

"Does my decision upset you?" I asked with irritation. She was pushing her limits now and I could easily deny her an orgasm for the night; the rest of the week, even.

"No, Miss Vega!" she quickly recovered. "I need to learn a lesson. Please teach me to be a good girl." I couldn't deny her begging was perfected. She said exactly what I wanted to hear and I knew she meant every word of it. Kneeling over my bed with her hands tied behind her back, she was completely vulnerable to me. I savored her obedience just as much as her disregard.

From my closet I pulled out a small purple butt plug I had been thrilled to find. It was tiny and slim; perfect for an anal virgin. She had been spanked once today and even allowed me to explore her rear end with my finger. Before Cay I had never tried anal with another woman but every inch of my young student enticed me. Touching her every orifice had begun to seem natural to me. I wanted all of her.

"Open your mouth," I told her as I returned to her side. She spread her lips apart and I slowly slid the new plug into her mouth for her to suck on. She did just that, evaluating the shape and probably wondering to herself of its use. I began to press my index finger into her ass once again, measuring just how tense she had become. Cay moaned as I massaged her rim, taking my time to relax her muscles before I attempted penetrating her again.

"I'm going to stick this plug inside of you, and you're going to wear it for the rest of the night." As my intentions became clear Cay squirmed beneath me while her nerves worked themselves up again. I began to enjoy the feeling of her muscles tensing up, especially with my finger pressed into her sphincter. Her resistance was almost a challenge in itself. Regardless of what she tried she would have to participate and I would have my way in the end.

"Get it nice and wet," I told her as I once more set upon the lube and squeezed another dollop between her cheeks. "That's a good girl," I cooed softly, using one hand to spread it over her asshole. I began to rub my thumb over her rosebud to massage her back into a calmer state of mind. Cayla had done exactly as I had suggested because I noticed a thin string of dribble stretch out from her lips as I pulled the plug out of her mouth. While I lined the tip of the rubber toy against her rim Cayla began to pant once more. I used one hand to spread her cheek apart while the other began to press the plug inside of her.

"Ahhh," Cay moaned while I worked the plug into her little by little.

"Tell me why you're being punished, Cay," I commanded as I rubbed the purple plug against her sphincter again and again. The more I massaged her ass the more she began to loosen up. Soon the tip was starting to disappear inside of her.

"I'm a bad girl," Cay quickly responded, learning from her punishment in the classroom of how she was expected to respond. "I need to be taught to behave. Not to... ahhh... N-not to talk back when you've given me a command." The plug slid in a little deeper and I began to pump it in and out of her, pushing a little further each time.

"That's right. You deserve this toy up your ass, don't you?" I began to swirl the plug as I pressed into her, circling the pressure to touch on all angles of her inner walls. Cay was breathing heavily by now.

"Yes, Miss Vega," she huffed.

"I want you to wear this all night. That way you won't quickly forget why you're being punished. Does this seem fair to you?" The toy was nearly inside of her completely now. I resisted pressing it in all the way to avoid her sphincter from tightening around the thin base at the end. I wanted to keep her stretched out while I made her rehearse the best phrases I had ever heard leave her lips. She was pushing me to the edge with her words alone. I wanted to fuck her brainless the more she assured me of her compliance.

"Yes, of course Miss Vega."

"Would you agree this is a fair punishment for any future misbehaving I catch you doing?" I wondered if she could hear the smile in my voice. I never stopped fucking her ass with the rubber toy while I spoke. My eyes were fixated on the sight of her tight asshole sucking on the plug I filled her with. She had stopped tensing up against my assault allowing the purple rubber to slide in and out of her freely.

"Yes, Miss Vega," she moaned once more.

"Tell me, Cayla. Tell me what should happen to you when you're a bad girl." She had never been pushed to these limits before. I had only just acquired my student's submission a day ago and yet here I found myself crouched between her legs filling her with a butt plug for the very first time. I knew I wanted to do this again, to test her anal limits once more. I wanted Cay's verbal agreement to allow it.

"You should bend me over and put a toy up my ass. Please, Miss Vega make me wear it for the rest of the night so I learn a lesson. I deserve to have a plug in my ass when I'm a bad girl. Please teach me a lesson!" At that I pressed the plug the rest of the way inside of her and applied an up and down pressure against the base with my thumb. Cay bit her lip while hums of pleasure slipped through her gritted teeth. I grabbed the base and slowly pulled the plug back out of her and Cayla twitched as her sphincter let go of it's tight grip over the toy. Then with even pressure I pressed it back into her, watching her rim close once more over the thin neck of the plug.

"Good girl," I cheered softly as I grabbed at her bound wrists and pulled her up off the bed. Before she could get comfortable standing I spun her around and directed her to lay back down, now on her back. When I pushed at her thighs she positioned herself so her legs were hanging off of the side, spread and presented in front of me. She rested over her cuffed arms which pushed her breasts up nicely. If I had more patience I might have clipped her with nipple clamps but I was so sexually frustrated that I could hardly think straight anymore. The first thing I did was reach for the vibrator I had set aside and activate it once more. Cay froze, expecting to be on the receiving end once again but I quickly plunged it into my own nether regions instead. Relief filled my every nerve and I moaned loudly as a new ecstasy built up inside of me. My eyes fluttered half way shut and I had to fight closing them to avoid missing Cay's head perk upwards in surprise, needing her ears to clarify what she was hearing. I was masturbating beside her and there was nothing she could do to see it or assist. I carefully lowered myself to my knees as more gratified moans slipped through my lips. Cay's plugged butt hole was clear in my view and the memory of putting it there pushed me further to the edge. Cay fidgeted in her place and I couldn't help but think her mind had to be spinning with curiosity.

"Tell me what you're thinking, Cay." This time I was the one with the heated breaths. My body wanted to erupt. Cay would help get me there.

"I want to touch you, Miss Vega."

"How could you when your hands are tied?" I pumped the small vibrator in and out of me then turned the speed up to it's highest.

"I could use my mouth," she bargained in an adorable fashion.

"But you've never eaten a woman out, have you?" She paused, her inexperience now holding her back.

"N-No, Miss Vega but I could-"

"I don't like when girls don't know what they're doing."

"Will you teach me how, Miss?" Her voice was softer now, her insecurities coming to life before me. I stared at her wet entrance and bit on my own lip. The climax I had been waiting so patiently for was well on it's way.

"Why?" I was well aware of the answer and eager to hear it from Cay's lips.

"I want to please you, Miss Vega. I want to touch you so badly."

"I love when you beg, Cayla." I pressed the vibrator deeper inside of me as my orgasm rolled forth.

"Please let me eat you out. Please Miss Vega let me touch you, and please you. I want you to use me like a toy to make you cum. I want to be your toy. I'll do anything you ask me to. Will you please let me be your toy?"

"Ahh!" I cried as my cream dripped down to my fingers, my climax sending waves of euphoria through my every muscle. "No, Cay." I was panting as I recovered. "You can't be my toy tonight." Cay squirmed as she realized her moment had passed, her begging going unheard. I could visibly see the distress on her face though she hid her frustrations for fear of misbehaving again. "But maybe someday soon when you've been a very good girl." I pulled the vibrator out from inside of me and turned it off.

"Open your mouth." She did as she was told as I carefully leaned over her and inserted the small device coated with my orgasm. When I lowered myself back down I kissed her swollen clit and set about finishing the task I had started. Cay squealed, her voice muffled by the vibrator she sucked on greedily. My finger carefully found her entrance and slipped inside of her to begin another rhythm within her walls. I was floating on cloud nine, cleaning her of all her juices while finally able to penetrate her with my own hand. Cay's hips rocked back and forth in sync with me. She was tender to the touch, every swirl of my tongue summoning more moans forward. I flicked my tongue back and forth against her clitoris while I fought to fit a second finger within her tight pussy. Cay groaned against the pressure of my hand, clearly fighting to allow me inside of her. I once more took my time opening her up little by little. Each time I pulled out of her I pushed my way back further just a tad more. My other hand snaked around the plug that had just started to get settled within her and pulled on it so that her asshole was once more being stretched by the largest part of the toy. At this point Cay was squirming uncontrollably. I worked her from both ends, filling all of her holes and feeling damned proud of myself for doing so. I heard her spit the vibrator out as a loud cry escaped her lips.

"Eden, I'm going to cum. Please allow me to cum! Oh god, Eden. Please please, tell me I can cum." Her begging was like music to my ears. I wondered how she knew just what to say to me to make me crave her even more. There was nothing in the world I wanted more than to give her what she wanted then.

"Cum my little fuck toy," I answered, finally understanding how a domme could call their submissives vulgar names with no disregard for their feelings. I realized then Cay wanted to be my fuck toy. She had begged for it. "You have my permission."

"Ughhhh!" She arched her back as her pussy tightened against my fingers. I pushed the plug all the way back into her ass and doubled my efforts on her vaginal entrance, creating a loud squishing noise as her orgasm sloshed out of her. Cay was heaving for air while I slowed down and waited for her to regain her sanity. When I pulled my fingers out of her I once again delighted in cleaning her from the base of the plug all the way up to her clit. She squirmed when I sucked on the small bead, her hypersensitivity beyond her control. Her creamy juices got all over my lips and cheeks but I didn't care. I had successfully collected Cayla Draxler's virginity. As she calmed herself I helped Cay back to her feet and turned her around to unhook her restraints. Then I set about undressing her of her blindfold before gathering the rest of her toys and taking them back to my closet. I was not surprised this time to turn and find Cay staring at me, her familiar gaze once more reaching my core. Even though I was naked she kept steady eye contact with me as I returned to her side. I pressed my lips onto her own and kissed her as passionately as I knew how. Whatever I felt for this girl was beyond just a fun screw. I had invited her into my home, dressed her, and now claimed her as my own. I had many more nights planned and more ideas in store for my student who was no longer a virgin.

"Get in bed," I directed as I moved about the room to set an alarm and turn out the lights. With everything settled I crawled in after her and once more pulled her close to me. Her body was warm and I imagined my own was just the same; our exploits heating us up. Cay fit nicely against my chest and I couldn't help but enjoy the rhythm of her breathing against my skin. It was a feeling I could get used to waking up beside. She made no mention of the toy left between her butt cheeks and I partly looked forward to removing it for her the next morning.