All Comments on 'Friend Request Accepted'

by BTTap

Sort by:
  • 116 Comments
AnonymousAnonymous3 months ago

So lame

AnonymousAnonymousabout 1 year ago

The writer has absolutely no talent. Nothing in his stories holds u…they are so watered down..insipid…bland… !

AnonymousAnonymousabout 1 year ago
fuck him

he's a cheater too

SunnyU2SunnyU2over 1 year ago

She was wrong, but he was still half in love with Maria. He wasn't fully committed either. They got married too soon.

SarahwithloveSarahwithloveover 1 year ago

Sad story. A good example of how two people in love, can drift apart without realizing it until it is too late. Communication could have prevented things, but maybe not. Sometimes you just choose the wrong person.

AnonymousAnonymousover 2 years ago

A good story. I enjoyed reading it but I thought the MC was a bit of a dickhead. He stupidly loses the true love of his life by cheating on her so perhaps karma has had it's way.

Legio_Patria_NostraLegio_Patria_Nostraover 2 years ago

FTDS!!! Find Johnny Boy in a dark alley and stomp his neck....

nixroxnixroxalmost 3 years ago

3 stars and DITTO what everyone below is saying.

WargamerWargamerover 3 years ago

A good but sad story. Her lover will ditch her. My bet, he more interested in fucking a married woman on his term. Now she is free and ready for a commitment from him, he will cut and run.

After all, who wants to take up with a cheater?

She cheated for him, she’ll cheat on him if it suits her, plus she gets gets a better payout from him.

It is a given he’ll cheat on her first chance he gets.

In the end she destroyed her marriage for nothing, she is the loser bigtime,

and everyone will know what a whore she is.

ErotFanErotFanover 3 years ago
A good story

The build up and back story were a little long and rambling; although written in the style of a college student of that age.

The Meat of the story, the infidelity, was somewhat dispassionate and matched the tenor of the lead up. Too little drama for all the preliminary effort.

I often ask for an epilog with "clipped" stories. But in this case, there is not much emotional investment in the characters and what happens to them. He'll try to reconnect with Maria. She'll muddle around in banal valley for awhile, the guy won't be interested in a commitment. They will both continue working for their company, stiffly aware of each other.

AnonymousAnonymousover 3 years ago
WORDY

Too much extraneous, unneeded info.

Even with skipping and scanning, I gave up just before the end of page one.

Paul in Oklahoma

WargamerWargamerover 3 years ago

A conniving manipulative bitch, he is way better off without her.

As to her, she may not realise it now, but she has lost bigtime. Her lover will not want her and he does not please her anyway. Lots more suffering heading her way.

Good!!!!!

Scores 4/5

AnonymousAnonymousover 3 years ago
She was easy to leave.

The wife who wasn't. She represented nothing.

AnonymousAnonymousover 4 years ago
Written well technically

One problem is that "William" is inconsistently written. At one point he is clear about infidelity being a deal breaker. Good, clear character development. Then he changes and becomes almost ambivalent and a considerably weaker character. If you wanted to change William from a strong male into a weaker one, there needed to be some sort of bridge in the character development to get there.

DogFuzzDogFuzzover 4 years ago
Mixed opinion

I felt you used too much of your story time durning his high school and college years with his relationships. Then his actual marriage discussion was too brief for me. The part I enjoyed most was his internal discussion with himself as to he should do to his wife and “friend”. You put some real thought in that area. Thanks for sharing.

26thNC26thNCover 4 years ago
Again

Except for the one cuckold story, I really like this author's work. Enjoyed this again.

AnonymousAnonymousover 4 years ago
Really!!

Julie is such an idiot - and of course , a slut as well! She gets no physical satisfaction with the asshole, so how long will the connection last before she cheats again?! A well told story and quite realistic. Could have had another chapter, going into the aftermath of the divorce. Still, a good story.

calibammacalibammaover 4 years ago
Bad ending

Other than the bad ending, it was a nice story I gave it 4 ⭐️ and I favorited it...you know we all wanted to know Mary history and how they fared.

etchiboyetchiboyalmost 5 years ago
This had a very... real feel to it.

Wish it it could have been a little more exciting; maybe “pulled” me in emotionally a little more. Haven’t given much thought on how just yet, so no suggestions. Else I’d have given it one more star.

4-stars.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 5 years ago

Entirely waaaaaay too much explaining and talking by him at the end. Honestly, he basically dredged up everything that has already been talked about the first 2 pages. After a while, it becomes tedious.

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 6 years ago
UNBELIEVABLE

...that you got 100% approval from Harry in Virginia. I do not remember a comment from him with no criticism. I totally agree with HIV, and I do not remember that happening before.

The confrontation that HIV approves may be the best I've read -- and that includes MANY Loving Wives stories.

This story drops from 5 to 4 stars because of problems already elaborated on -- too wordy backstory (I skimmed) and an ending that, though good, is insufficient.

The story writing and dialog is actually quite good.

Paul in Oklahoma

26thNC26thNCalmost 6 years ago
Not bad

I have enjoyed all BBTap's stories , except for the cuckold crap. Although I would like a stronger husband, I enjoyed this one also.

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 6 years ago
Skimmed it

Just another sucky Cuck story. Get a life.

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 6 years ago
1*

Needed an ending where he moved the fuck on and forgets the tramp. No ending? One star

AnonymousAnonymousover 6 years ago

Another story with absolutely no ending........

AnonymousAnonymousover 6 years ago
wannabe thug or wannabe cuck?

both are virgins, both have neckbeards, both live in mommy's basement, both read/spank/leave a nasty comment on every cuck story on the site...

I think we have a winner!

LOL

AnonymousAnonymousover 6 years ago
Slamdogs butthurt outburst was more entertaining

Than the story I just skimmed.

LordSlamdawggLordSlamdawggabout 7 years ago
@ last wannabe thug comment

You have an theoretically excellent plan. Too bad all your friends are idiots like you and would no doubt leave a plethora of evidence leading to their ( and your ) inevitable conviction. If only you had one strong and smart buddy who could do the job solo . But nahhh. They're all weak losers ( which is why superior manpower is essential to overwhelm solitary lothario).

If only you had better friends ...but for that to happen you would have to be a better man . But if you were a better man , your woman wouldn't have wandered off in first place. What a bitch. This is all her fault. If only you could get a better girlfriend. ..

AnonymousAnonymousabout 7 years ago
What the guy gets off scottfree?

Not if it was me. I would first have a good alibi, then I would get a couple of my acquaintance (not close friends) to pay him a visit. The acquaintances would be guys who's girlfriends/wifes cheated on them. Thus they would really like to hurt this guy! Just break all of his fingers and toes. This doesn't represent severe bodily harm. You haven't hurt him badly but he now knows not to do that again.

AnonymousAnonymousover 7 years ago
Friend Request?

What Friend Request? How did that get into the story? Ah! Maria! Again! BS! LOL

AnonymousAnonymousover 8 years ago
cheating

its so horrible how now alienation of affection is in the past now a single guy can sleep with somones wife with little to no repurcussions

EddboyEddboyover 8 years ago
house is in her name

to the anon who posted last.. its technically her house which you'd know if you read the story

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 9 years ago
not a wimp but a fucking moron

I never can figure out why the guy fucking moves. He didn't cheat so why is the man always fucking leaving make the bitch leave

gdjohn52gdjohn52almost 9 years ago

Isnt it funny that women are always have lame excuses for be "intellectual", What a cunt

AnonymousAnonymousover 9 years ago
Good story

I don't see a wimp of a husband, at least no coward. The story shows the husband working lots of his time on the road? His actions were tops, comes home early, discovers the truth and does his own surveillance work. The wife was the main issue, her lack of respect, trust and willingness to fulfill her commitment to the marriage. When times were tough she moved into the arms of another man without ever considering her husband. The highlight was capturing their sexual encounter on camera how priceless is that. Now, in real life, a man or husband such as depicted would smile at her and simply say lie about me and I destroy you... fucking destroy you. But, your lover is going to be toast no matter what. For me, I do not condone cheating. Divorce and move on.. if there is love there, just be friends with benefits until someone special comes along. In a time that so many fight for same sex marriage, I would like to see laws protecting and enforcing marriage. This business owner would stand to loose so much had such laws been in place. I wonder if he would consider a married woman again after losing half of his investments to the husband on alienation of affection. I am however curious just whom posted a Friend Request Accepted, I am betting that Maria was that friend

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 10 years ago
written like a woman

in other words it sucks, no emotion by the male, and the self dialogue is pure pro female, men dont feel or get upset and really like a......British guy or mm or so many other pussy writers on this sight it was all his fault and she deserves her freedom?

personally she needs a beating a physical reflection of the emotional pain, women fear physical violence but they are so socially equipped to deal with emotional damage, and this is the opposite for men, so destroy her belief in a safe world for awhile, she had no mercy or respect for him return the favor,

violence can send a message, destroy her social protection email the pics to her friends and family, mercy is for the weak not a cheating healthy wife, to think otherwise is the reason terrorists win....you do not show respect to a fire or show compassion to it you put it out, 7 1/2 billion people time to say no!

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 10 years ago
Your wrote a story about a guy who is completely DEAD

He has no life, no self respect, no energy, no motivation, no feelings, and he wouldn't even pass a basic pysch exam. I wouldn't want this pathetic excuse for a person to be an employee, a friend, neighbor, father or spouse. Of course in reality it is the author BTTap who is a complete waste since this guy is just in your imagination.

It's a reflection.. a reflection on your sad and pathetic life. You show NO, not some, not a little, absolutely NO passion in this story... not one sentence, not one word.

I had hoped that you went on to do something about your life... but I see you didn't. Very sorry for you.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 10 years ago
Not what I expected

Based on the Loving Wives genre, I hope the couple would sort things out and move on. At least Julie tried to beg for another chance just like William did when he first cheated on Maria.

But the funny thing is he might go for the role of seducing Maria (prolly someone else's wife) by FB friendship request.

AnonymousAnonymousover 10 years ago
Haha

another wimp ass got blindsided with all the 'I love you' crap.

AnonymousAnonymousover 10 years ago
Thanks

To me, this one calibrates closer to reality than most. No drama, no revenge, realistic levels of pain, and prompt, decisive resolution. Well done.

AnonymousAnonymousover 10 years ago
u cud reely use

a author trainin

AnonymousAnonymousover 10 years ago
Fairly good story.

Seemed pretty realistic. You could have used an editor to help with some of the passages. The ending felt like real life.

sugnasugnaover 10 years ago
A taste of his own medicine

Funny how many cheaters can't stand the taste of their own medicine! Now he knew how Maria had felt years before.

AnonymousAnonymousover 10 years ago
You Could Really Use An Editor

To trim some of that excess backstory down a bit, but great effort. Plus, mad props for name-checking Prince. Always dug The Gold Experience.

amyyumamyyumover 10 years ago
Regarding your email re Tough Love

I didn't want to send a reply email. Of course you can do anything you want and I have no right to complain, but it was very nice and polite of you to ask. Please go ahead,and I hope you get better reception than I did (ha, ha -- not that I care)!

hawkeye0007hawkeye0007almost 11 years ago
Flat

No emotion...just boring, I hated the wife in this story.

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 11 years ago
Does 100's comments a month here

make you a no-life cockless loser? yep, proof is in the pudding, and betrayed loves him some pudding.

betrayedbylovebetrayedbylovealmost 11 years ago
Great Tale

It didn't have any of the revenge usually associated with these tales. It was more real than fiction. It could happen. It isn't exciting but that makes it even more appealing. No bullshit. Just reality. You cheat, you get divorced. Cut and dry.

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 11 years ago
Just right. Not too hard, not too soft.

Finally an author who knows how to deal with a cheating wife, gently divorce her. No humiliation, no revenge. No crying, no attempt at reconciliation. No last fuck for lean times ahead, no eating creampie. Just promptly let her go, and no looking back. Just right. I like it.

lance_spearmanlance_spearmanalmost 11 years ago
Good story

No unrealistic scenarios (millionaires, ex-SEAL, etc.) Just a plausible situation.

Thanks.

FireFox59FireFox59almost 11 years ago
WHY???

Did you stop??? Obviously there's more to the story.

elHosedelHosedalmost 11 years ago
Decently written...

...grammer, spelling, and over all flow was well done.

However, I have to agree with a previous commenter in that the husband doesn't come off as genuine. A little talked about fact with men is ultimately, when wronged, we really (I mean REALLY really) want to hurt something. This guy comes off as a guy being told his lease expires in a month and the landlord doesn't want to renew.

Drbeamer3333Drbeamer3333about 11 years ago

Thanks or the effort.

monkcalmmonkcalmabout 11 years ago
chick flick

gave it a 1 BTTap were to begin if your a guy im a monkeys uncle, oh so civilized sit down and discuses betrayal and lies... please... your not a man because the story has zero passion or love shit like this fucks us up and yeah she needed a beating, so you must be a woman because its go guy stupid...you get mad get cold hard and you dont care why! the reading was like pulling teeth "She nodded yes.""Julie, I love you, too. You fucked up. Maybe I did, too"- romance novel clap trap for women by women to ease a guilty mind, Yawn its all so rehashed feminist drivel. you dont have to burn but you dont have to make the male character pussies or some weird cuckold fetish thing, but if it turns your crank on keep writing this style some people like it but give us a feminist warning

AnonymousAnonymousover 11 years ago
9mm

is always a good solution.

AnonymousAnonymousover 11 years ago
Keep going

Could use a chapter two.

AnonymousAnonymousover 11 years ago
Needs work

Couple of points: The interior dialogue is good and believable, albeit tedious at times. The paragraphs are too long, break them up. When you get to the conversations they flow well but the participants, esp. the final confrontation, seem a little bloodless. Perhaps you worked on this story over a period of time because it appears to consist of different stories stuck together, like you had trouble finding your voice. That said, I gave it a 4 for storytelling. Keep at it, you have the makings of a good writer and I look forward to reading more of your work.

Huedogg2Huedogg2over 11 years ago
Why haven't I seen this before

This was a great story, I'm impressed. BTTap your always commenting about staying together so I thought you were one of those WACC/RACC lovers. This was outstanding, revenge wasn't needed and the marriage wasn't worth fighting for. 5*'s

BTTapBTTapalmost 12 years agoAuthor
Thanks RRW

Glad you liked the story, and I remember the anon comment you referenced.

Hope you are doing well. Thanks for your service.

BTW-I will have a couple of new stories out soon.

RonRWoodRonRWoodalmost 12 years ago
It was good and real...

I became entranced with Maria at the first and his unintentional cheating, and what it cost him. I did not take his relationship with Julie quite as serious, especially in the way you described it as being. It was her making the decisions and providing the friends, the house, and the job for him. It appeared by your description that he was just going along for the ride. He was not that wounded I think, because he still wanted to correct his previous mistake with Maria and knew he could get over Julie easy enough. As you described...they were not "in love" anymore.

I went through this myself in my first marriage and recognized the events. My first wife cheated when I was gone all the time and we had lost touch with each other. She found another to keep her company though she did not want to divorce me. She only became remorseful when I had left her for another. This is personally what I look for in these stories:

You are a very good writer and will become even better I can tell. I know you put a lot of thought into this story. I think you are a considerate and feeling person as well. A while back you were the only one that answered a plea comment from an anon that asked a somewhat personal question about betrayals in general, betrayals other than cheating.

Thank you for this story BTTap. OldMarineVet - RonRWood

cpetecpetealmost 12 years ago

I have to agree with all the other poster about what a fine story this was. The ending was the most realistic I think I have read on this site. Hubby confronts, wife lies, then makes excuses and finally comes clean. BT had hubby in "Game Over" mode before the conversation, the hubby character was just looking for closure and a few answers in the inal coversation..

Revenge, why bother? BT did well to show Hubby character wanted to move on, no use beating a dead horse. Most cheating marriages end in a wimper, not a bang, as you have written. Should the wife have suffered consquenses (byond the divorce, loss of hubby)? BT did a nice job of showing hubby felt he was her husband, not her parent, not his job to "teach her a lesson."

I do also agree with posters who say you have a Part II available from this tale. Does hubby hook with Maria? X-wife finally find out why John is not married and has a 14 year old son? My best bet would be POV from wife -starting about mid way thru the affair, going thru her getting burned by John, wrapping up with her years later seeing X-hubby and Maria with the 2.5 kids and Maria pregant (but please do make Maria another war widow)

Again thanks for a fine tale. Looking forward to more.

roscovichroscovichalmost 12 years ago
At long last,an inteligent and competent author.

I was amazed at this writer excellent style. All I can say,apart from awarding 5*, that I shall be looking forward to read more of this author. Thank you.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 12 years ago
Good story

Many thanks. I enjoyed it, and it is obvious that you put a lot of thought, and a lot of work into it. Some real lessons to be learned here.

RopergirlRopergirlover 12 years ago
Great read!

Loved this one! Also agree with some of the comments that it was well ended but would love to see a sequel or two just to see how they both end up.

AnonymousAnonymousover 12 years ago
Why can't anyone FINISH a story?

.?

Stii_AnonymousStii_Anonymousover 12 years ago
Very realistic

Thoroughly enjoyed this story. One of the most realistic storylines on Lit. You did a very good job rationalizing Williams actions, although I do think he was lacking emotion when he saw the sex between the wife and lover and at the end of the story. It seemed a little too clinical. All in all much improvement from the first story.

AnonymousAnonymousover 12 years ago
Lame

That is 5 minutes of my life I won't get back! The story was about nothing and didn't go anywhere and was full of far too much backgrond information that added nothing to the story. I read on in the hope it would take a twist or turn and become half exciting! Sadly that didnt happen.

PolyLvrPolyLvrover 12 years ago
Well told

I fund a bit of the backstory was tedious but I relaize some of it's points were important. I enjoyed the rest of it.

I'm glad it wasn't one of those macho, over-the-top revenge stories. This was probably, minus some screaming, a more realistic tale.

DunaDunaover 12 years ago

I think William did not find out the affair and the loverboy chaned her for a newer woman, she would have cheated again some years later with a other man. She slowly would have become a serial cheater If the loverboy ended the affair after the divorce, it could be a traumatic event, which would assist her to become a better personality in a second marriage. It may be I am a little optimistic.

greowulfgreowulfover 12 years ago
one more thing

I think I have to disagree with HDK for once. I also usually skip a long backstory, but the Maria story and Linda's scene at the bar actually added to this one.

greowulfgreowulfover 12 years ago
excellent story

Well written and realistic. Walked a very balanced line betwee TTB and reconciliation. The commentary on human nature, trust, and the motivations behind the tgwo different types of infidelity was spot on. Bravo.

Don't pay attention to the detractors. He got a fairer settlement than he otherwise would have (if MN is not a community property state), and Julie is in for a lot of tears down the road. She will soon realize how well he treated her, and you simply cannot trust someone you had an affair with. There is probably a reason he is still single at 40, and that reason will haunt her if she takes up with him.

DunaDunaover 12 years ago
Human nature

I do not agree some commenters, because this divorce was a emotional shock for Julie and she would suffer for a long time against the remained lover boy.

Our behavioral is different so at Julie the break up will couse bigger suffer than William will have. Julie has not decided on any divorce yet, she wanted to sit on 2 horsebacks for a long time before she will decide on something. The abrupt caught will couse much bigger emotional pain at Julie than William, because Williem started the divorce and the great scen with the caugth. The divorce would have been neutral for Julie, if she had decide on the divorce or she had been a slut. She was a simple cheater who wanted to have 2 men in her life. William was succesful because it happened befor any children project. William after the consequence will heal up psichicalic quickler than Julie will do, because his brain closed this chapter of his life only his emotional brain has to follow his will. Julie is a woman whose has to process emotional he was denied..............And We do not know the lover boy wants to end his bachelor life???!!!! If the lover boy want a newer prey for himself Julie will fell on the ground between 2 horses, and the divorce will be immidiatly a Romantic Revenge.....I wrote earlier epiloge, epiloge, epiloge........

FD45FD45over 12 years ago
This was much better then your first attempt

It had realism and pathos. It described real relationships.

I'd have liked a bit more to happen to her, but I suppose the best thing that happened to him was in the final line.

DunaDunaover 12 years ago
A praise

@ Dear Ms. Dwornock I am glad and welcome for your surprise positive comment.

DWornockDWornockover 12 years ago
Excellent! I rated it 5 stars.

Very logical and mostly realistic. And, somewhat erotic. Thank you writing it.

AnonymousAnonymousover 12 years ago
But, when I saw how deeply involved I was with John, I guess the feelings were too strong, the attraction was too strong to pull away."

Yeah right, and I own a condo on Mars.

Good thing he tossed her out because sooner or later she'd find some other joker to make chemistry with.

ParPlus10ParPlus10over 12 years ago
Good Story.

This was a fresh and more realistic look at cheating and divorce. It makes me think back to years ago when my brother's wife cheated on him. He divorced and forgot about her. There are always those who need to have some severe payback or revenge. I wonder if it's just bitterness over their own lives.

Sometimes you need to just move on and forget it. I'm not a big user of Facebook, but maybe William shows it does have some value.

I did find myself skipping over some of the parts that were pretty dry. Also, there could have been more dialog. I think in this story demonstrates that the absence of dialog can indicate that the story could be tightened up.

Great effort and thanks for the story!

zed0zed0over 12 years ago
A Little Light But A Good Read

Julie got off way too lightly. I mean, Willy spoke harshly to her. Wow! How terrifying! Maybe he'll stamp his foot next, that should make her feel really bad for the next ten minutes.

He wrongly assumed publishing the pictures would get him in trouble, and he would get caught. But it's next to impossible to catch someone, even for a "super spy" agency.

The boy friend skated completely, which just isn't right!

The penalty for screwing around with a married women, is irate husbands causing bodily harm and possibly grievous injury.

It's like the law of the jungle or something.

Let's face it, Willy is a passive wuss, who let her walk all over him, small wonder she had no respect.

Although I found Willy mildly frustrating, I did enjoy the story. It was well done and very realistic, but realism can get a little pedantic and isn't always that much fun to read.

FWIW - I did give you five stars

bruce22bruce22over 12 years ago
Good and well produced story.

The title put me off initially, because being a dinosaur I do not know about

Facebook!! I thought that it sounded like a pure cuck story with a title like that.

But after reading a few comments and coming up dry today, I dug in and really enjoyed it. The comments about the problems as seen through the author's eyes

are right on, and I have to agree 100% with Harry!?!

DunaDunaover 12 years ago
Human behavioral of the majority of the people

A little discuss about the human nature. The constant partnership is a strong emotional brackground, if the partner as William gentle husband, good provider and good sexual partner. The divorce is a strong break in Julie's soul against the loverboy will reamain for her. We do not know much about the bachelor loverboy he will change his mind and Julie will be the wedding aim for him?? If this bachelor who lived for the predator lifstyle he will be a faithful husband???? The divorce dicade was strong emotional pain for Julie and a consequence story wife character can suffer harder as the husband who decide on the divorce. To drift apart may be suffer for the cheater, who has losted the strong background for a simple cheater or a serial cheater wife. This is much less true for a slut wife.

digdaddyrichdigdaddyrichover 12 years ago
An enjoyable tale

A nicely written storyline and believable story. A little sad that he went through so much trouble with his love life.

Thanks for the read

Mousse9Mousse9over 12 years ago

To anon (gods, I hate replying to anons), I never said spending years "in a frenzy of pain and anger, obsessed with revenge". Those are YOUR words. THAT is what you think? I never even MENTIONED the word revenge.

If you rob a bank, you're caught, and you get a stern talking-to without a fine, or jailtime, THAT is getting off scotfree. No consequences.

Julie got the same treatment. She got caught, got a stern talking-to from William, and that's it. And like I said in my previous comment, divorce won't hurt her too much because William isn't screwing her over financially, and they had already grown apart, so no emotional pain either.

If there had been SOME consequences for her actions, that would've sat better with me.

Pfch, 18 months in a frenzy of pain and anger, obsessed with revenge. Get a life.

Vulcan_in_OhioVulcan_in_Ohioover 12 years ago
Pretty good read

Some editing to fix a few mistakes, plus a bit of trimming for unnecessarily long paragraphs, and it would be a five. The content and story line were good, and it was credible, with no wimpy behavior on the part of hubby. 4.5/5.0 -- thanks for writing.

AnonymousAnonymousover 12 years ago
She had it coming

Any spouse who engages in adultery deserves being divorced.

chytownchytownover 12 years ago
Good Read!!

Thanks for sharing.

AnonymousAnonymousover 12 years ago
You're shitting me, right??

This is only your second story?!?!?

A brilliant effort, and for once, I'm in complete agreement with HarryinVA. Wonderful effort.

nakdsubnakdsubover 12 years ago
I guess I'm not quite as enthusiastic...

I did enjoy the story. There is one section when the story goes from past tense to present tense then back to past. That was very annoying to me. Also, I thought it ended a little abruptly.

I couldn't give it 5, but I gave it 4*.

AnonymousAnonymousover 12 years ago
What if---------

John, being in the "Restaurant Business" was "Connected" and took a dim view of those pictures being in existence????????????? Could mean trouble for our hero.

demantoiddemantoidover 12 years ago
WOW! What a great short story!

I just thoroughly enjoyed your saga BTTap. You communicated a warmth through your character William that was so compelling and thrilling. I raced through each sentence and paragraph with smiles and tension...delicious writing and plotting. Your description of college life was a terrific snapshot. Giving the wife a bit of leeway based on the Maria incident, added to the wonderful humanity to your story and to William. Brilliant. Thank you for letting me share and relish your storytelling talents BTTap.

Rockyderek_caRockyderek_caover 12 years ago
Great

Now having presented us a very realistic set of events.... What becomes of our intrepid hero. Aftercall he did wish his former gitlfriend to forgive him?? Albeit a different level of cheating, the wife betrayed the heart of the marriage long before the sex.... And he knowingly got polluted at a party knowing his own level of behavior while polluted... So is one worse than the other? A commitment is a commitment with or without the marriage papers. Look forward to chapter two. Thanks for writing.

Harryin VAHarryin VAover 12 years ago
absolutely fabulous story

100% perfect. What makes so this SOOOOOOOO good is that the author actually FOCUSES ON THE MEANING OF THE CHEATING .

god almighty I have been screaming about this for YEARS . In most LW stories the authors never have husband think about the MEANING of the wife actions/ words/ behavior / attitude.

In THIS story the BEST part was this bit of conversation

........"If you were just a selfish bitch who truly loved me but wanted a magnificent lover with a baby's arm for a cock, I might even have hope that you could get over that selfish fixation and recommit yourself to our marriage. Or, maybe I couldn't, but whatever. The point is, I know he isn't anything special in the sex department, but you did it anyway. *** Which MEANS, the issue is really about you and me and our marriage, and maybe the feelings you have for this John asshole. You either really love him, on some level, or you really don't love me enough. **** Either way, it's not worth fighting for." ...............

Bravo!!!! finally someone develops a man / Husband with BRAIN..

Finally.. finally....

looking4itlooking4itover 12 years ago
Nice Story

I did enjoy the story. Unless you plan a sequel I think the depth you went into about Maria was too long. While it could bring him some empathy (although it didn't really, did it) it wasn't really significant until the final line, so a shorter version would serve the beginning of this story as well. The other thing I noticed was when you mentioned some issues with their relationship early they really weren't tied in later. What I did appreciate the most was some of the calm and logical discussion at the end. Certainly some new insight into reasons and reactions.

AnonymousAnonymousover 12 years ago
there are some people who could move on

why revenge , he had class, he fiqured out what he wanted to do . moving on without killing the cheater..why does the male want to kill the cheater there were no kids and he gets his freedom. she will screw up again and this guy was just using her and will probabley move on himself. so she has nothing to fall back on

brujaybrujayover 12 years ago
Good Story

This was a good read. I think you will go far as an author if you follow the advice of some of the better writers on this site.

Thank you for sharing your story with us and please keep on writing.

Mostera1Mostera1over 12 years ago
Very nice

BTTap You keep getting better and better! I won't rehash what others have already said, and rather well too; except I would also like to see a fitting sequel. I know you will treat each character properly.

Well done!

Thank you!

M1

AnonymousAnonymousover 12 years ago
why not move on?

To the commenter who was upset that it seemed like "he's already forgiven her, and is just moving on." Yeah, it'd be much better if spent he next 18 months in a frenzy of pain and anger, obsessed with revenge. Really the path to a good life, that. He's calm because he's realized that the marriage was never very good and had turned to crap even before her affair -- he's at the blessed point where he can indeed just move on, hallelujah, have a life, look for something better. Seeking revenge would just be another way of letting her and her cheating control his life.

x_JohnDoe_xx_JohnDoe_xover 12 years ago
Good story.

I hope the husband lives happily everafter, I guess the wife will with her knew lover. Thanks for writing.

Mousse9Mousse9over 12 years ago

Jasonnh said it before me, but during the ending William seemed rather dispassionate, given the subject. Maybe because they had become very distant, but he barely showed any emotion during their "final talk". Either he's INCREDIBLY levelheaded, or he killed off his emotions.

And...I dunno, it just feels to me like Julie simply got off scotfree. Yeah, she's gonna get divorced, but that probably won't hurt her too much, given the fact that they've grown apart, she's cheating on him (respect and love for William gone), AND she has feelings for the other guy. Basically she just won't care and won't be hurt too much by divorce.

Yes, the threat of showing the pictures if she lies about the reason for divorce would be bad, I guess. But if people did ask, she COULD say that they had been growing apart for months, and she found someone better. Both she and William were to blame for the destruction of their marriage. Problem solved.

In my opinion, William was too lenient. Not in the divorce stuff, but it seems to me like he's already forgiven her, and is just moving on. I'm ambivalent about the ending.

Although this IS an ending, I WOULD like to see an epilogue of sorts, like Duna mentioned.

njlaurennjlaurenover 12 years ago
great story

My one critique is while descriptions and back stories are great it is very easy to get lost in them.Some of the space used for detailing the past could have been used to flesh out the emotions of both of them,especially at the end. I think this was a mature story that talks to the truth of why people can have affairs,it usually is because the spouse forgets what they have and goes looking for something to fill the need,the slut,size queen and such are rare compared to the emotional needs.This story is interesting because the sex is not the main reason for cheating,which rings true.As in DQS stories the emotional cheating started before the real cheating. The fact that she cannot say why she fell for the other guy tells volumes.

It would be interesting to see what happens.Is Maria next?Does the wife realize John used her,or was that real.I have to admit as a romantic that the couple finds their way back but William is probably dead on that there would be no way,that she could never make him feel respected or loved having given herself emotionally to someone else.

AnonymousAnonymousover 12 years ago
You sure go into a lot of detail

I skipped through some parts, sorry. Everyone but Maria is pretty shallow.

12
Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous