My Sister Made Me Ch. 01

He had his head propped up on his hands and looked distraught.

She knocked quietly on the door frame. "Pastor Dan, do you need anything else from me?"

Looking up, he brushed a tear from his eyes and shook his head.

"No, you're good to go ahead and go home. Thank you again for the help, Samantha." He forced a smile and spun in his chair, wiping his eyes.

Never one to leave a shoulder un-hugged in a time of need, she came around and spun him back around.

"Pastor Dan? What's wrong?" she asked.

He looked up and sighed. "It's nothing I should talk to you about," he said. "It's private, and between my wife and I." His facade crumbled quickly, though, and he started to cry softly. She quickly began to rub his shoulder and leaned over to offer him a hug.

"It's okay," she said, "Shh." She repeated her words of comfort as he cried, clutching at her and turning towards her. He stood after a few minutes and pulled her into a hug, squeezing her as his shoulders shook. After a minute, he pulled back and wiped his eyes. Releasing her, he grabbed a few tissues and blew his nose. She quietly stood by, still rubbing his shoulders.

He sighed and turned. "I'm sorry, Samantha. I shouldn't have lost it like that."

"Do you..." she started to say. "Is there anything I can do?"

He shook his head. "No, thanks. I'll be okay."

"Come on, you can tell me," she prompted, smiling at him and still rubbing his shoulder.

He sighed and turned. Taking a deep breath, he told her about how he thought his wife was having an affair. He spoke for awhile, and at the end, he seemed to feel better. It was as if talking had eased his pain a little. Finally smiling, he stood and pulled her into a hug again. She felt him lay his head on her shoulder for a moment. He inhaled deeply, his arms wrapped tightly around her, her own around his and her hand stroking the back of his head.

"Come on, now," she said. "Chin up. God has a plan for you," she said with a smile.

Still holding on, he backed up a little and smiled genuinely at her. She caught herself staring at him for a moment longer than she should have, and then cleared her throat. He suddenly leaned forwards and kissed her, catching her off guard and drawing a whimper of surprise.

"Pastor Dan!" she said suddenly, backing up. "You... we... I didn't mean to..." she stammered

He looked at her in shock and quickly covered his face. "Oh, Lord, what am I doing?" he sighed.

"No, no!" Sam said, quickly hugging him tight. "It was me, it was my fault!" she said, desperate to make him feel better.

"You'd probably better go," he said, "before I do something else to sabotage our friendship."

He patted her on the back and turned back to sit in his desk.

"I'll see you soon, okay?" she asked. "You didn't do anything wrong."

"You're very sweet, Samantha. Thank you letting me get that off my chest." He smiled as best he could and turned back to his computer.

She frowned, but knew that she should leave him alone, but definitely feeling bad about leaving him in his current state. Driving home, she felt like she'd led him on, or done something to cause him to think she wanted to comfort him in a different way. She promised herself that she'd talk to him sometime during the week and make sure he knew that he'd done nothing wrong and that she was sorry.

Still, the kiss was surprising, but it had made him feel better. Was that wicked of her? She turned the thought over and over in her head, but knew that she needed to talk to one of her sisters. Toni was promiscuous and freer with her body than Sam was comfortable with. She knew her advice would probably involve pushing her deeper into a bad situation.

Alex would be a good person to talk with. She was always a good listener and had helped her work out lots of awkward problems.

She drove home, went upstairs and poked her head into Alex's room. Seeing that she was still asleep, she headed back downstairs and made her a couple of turkey sandwiches and a drink.

*****

Alex

Feeling much better after her cleansing run, Alex went to the kitchen and got a bottle of water to quench her thirst. Her brother, Danny, snuck around the corner and slapped her hard on the ass.

Squealing in pain and clutching at her stinging butt cheek, she yelled at him and threw the water bottle.

"You son of a bitch!" she yelled.

Danny laughed as she slapped him a few times while he got in the fridge for something to drink.

"That fuckin' hurt," she said, wincing.

"Good," he said, heading back upstairs. "Love you!" he called back down.

"Fucker," she muttered, turning and following.

Halfway up, he farted loudly and she swore again, holding her nose and her breath as she finished walking up the steps.

"Fuckin' cave man," she yelled. She walked down the long hallway toward her room, but as she passed Toni's she heard low voices. There were clearly two people in her room talking, and one had a much lower pitch than the other. It must be Wade and Toni.

She sighed and passed by quietly, but could hear them through the long adjoining closet that they shared. Unique in design, their two rooms were the last at the end of the house, on either side of the hall with doors facing each other. The closet door was set in the very end of the hall, but formed a "T" shape between the two rooms with a door in each.

Alex's room was on the left, and Toni's the right. She laid down on her bed and pulled out her homework. Soft moans started to come from Toni's room after a few minutes, and caused Alex to laugh and close her eyes. Standing, she kicked off her shoes and crept quietly into their closet. The louvers on Toni's door were only slightly opened, so Alex snuck as quietly as she could through the closet until she'd reached her sister's door.

Cringing, she reached out and gently opened them. Toni was at the end of her bed, facing the closet. She looked up, seeing Alex peering through and immediately held up her hand to shush her.

Alex covered her mouth, and froze, her heart pounding. Wade's brown hair was between her sister's legs and he was bobbing his head back and forth. Toni winked and laid back further, her legs spreading. Alex couldn't see what he was doing exactly, but knew that her sister was really enjoying him going down on her. She saw his hand appear then, as he reached up and began to pull at Toni's nipple, his fingers squeezing and rolling it before he began to fondle and rub the entirety of her breast.

"I know you were getting pretty friendly with my sister last night. Did you behave yourself?" Toni asked, flashing Alex a grin.

Wade looked up from her crotch and chuckled. "Of course I did. You didn't talk to her yourself?"

Toni giggled and shook her head. "She's been sleeping all morning I think. Why? Do you wanna go in there and slide something into her?"

Alex hoped Toni could see her look of shock as she stood in the darkness. She held up a single middle finger for good measure.

"No way, baby," Wade said. "You're the one I want," he said.

She felt her heart sink then, feeling insulted and started to turn back to her room.

"You don't find my sister attractive?" Toni asked. "Why wouldn't you want to have sex with my sister?" She looked down at him sternly, as if he'd said the wrong thing. She moaned softly and moved against him. Alex couldn't be sure, but she thought he might have his finger inside of her.

"Oh, quite the opposite, baby. If I got to have sex with you and then your absolutely stunning sister, I think I could die a happy man. But seeing as I don't want to die yet, and having sex with the two of you would most likely kill any man, I figured I should decline."

"So you do want to have sex with my big sister?" Toni asked.

Wade smirked. "Yes, Toni. I'd love to slide in bed with her right now and then slide into her without waking her up."

Toni snickered and pushed his face back down to her pussy. Her eyes were on him mostly, but she checked every once in a while that Alex was still watching.

A few minutes of Wade's rhythmic licking and head bobbing at her crotch had Toni arching her back as an orgasm washed over her body. Alex couldn't help but watch in amazement as her entire body seemed to tense up at once, her nipples looking painfully erect atop her breasts, and her hands clutching desperately at Wade's hair. Finally spent, Toni lay there in bliss as Wade stood and began to remove his pants.

Her eyes going wide, Alex turned and began to head back to her own room, but something stopped her. She'd never seen an erect penis in person before, and as much as she wanted to deny it, seeing her sister have an orgasm was a turn on. Biting her lip and fighting briefly against the urge, she sighed and turned back. Slinking back into the racks of clothes, she tried to disappear into the fabric.

Wade was standing naked, his well-formed buttocks towards the closet. Swearing internally, Alex willed him to turn. Toni's eyes and forehead peered around his hips as she bobbed forwards and backwards. Mirth in her eyes, she winked and turned him, pushing him towards the bed. Sliding back against the wall, he was perpendicular to the closet door.

Subconsciously licking her lips, Alex gazed out from her hiding spot at her first real penis. The first thing she noticed was that it looked like it was in pain. It was ridiculously hard, standing angrily atop his groin as he shifted backwards in the bed and smiled down at Toni. His hand was slowly stroking it as he looked towards her.

Toni slid forwards and to her knees, smiling up at him seductively. Alex couldn't help herself, and slid her hand into her panties. Feeling how wet she'd become, she immediately felt shame wash over her, but still couldn't look away.

Wade's penis looked big, but she didn't really know for sure. It was her first one, after all. All she'd ever seen was her brothers' when they walked in on her in the bathroom or when they walked around in their underwear, and they weren't ever hard when that happened. It was definitely bigger than they were when they were soft, but that wasn't anywhere near a fair comparison.

She began to rub herself gently, biting into one of the hanging shirts to muffle her whimpers.

Toni was running her tongue across the tip of his cock, up and over the head, pushing it to a point and running it along the slit. Smiling, she lowered her lips over the tip, causing him to moan loudly and close his eyes.

Alex stood transfixed, her eyes glued to his cock. Toni lowered her face onto the shaft, slowly taking it into her mouth, as far as she could. Pushing her finger into herself, Alex slowly began to rub, eliciting a quiet sigh and closing her eyes for a moment. She sighed and looked back into the room. Toni was bobbing up and down on him faster now, her lips pursed and sliding wetly up and down his shaft, leaving a wet shine on his skin. Seemingly unable to take it anymore, he shook his head and quickly stood, pulling Toni up and onto the bed. She squealed in excitement and spread her legs quickly.

Alex knew she shouldn't keep watching the two. But her sister was perched in such a way that she could still look directly into the closet and at Alex. She winked at her then, and Alex blushed, her finger still gently massaging inside her pussy.

Wade scooted Toni towards him, and then leaned in. Alex began to have an orgasm as she saw him slide all the way into her sister. Her own pussy convulsed down on the finger she was pushing inside herself as she whimpered into the rack of clothes she was hiding in. Terrified she was making too much noise, she saw her sister staring directly towards her, a knowing smile on her face as Wade continued to slide in and out of her.

Pleasure flooded every cell in her body and she fell backwards against the wall. She willed herself to fade completely into nothingness, but she began to feel the effects of her orgasm diminish. She quietly crept back through the closet to her own room and crawled into bed, sleep coming quickly for her.

An hour or so later, a soft knock on her door drew her from her nap. "Come in," she muttered, wiping her eyes.

Toni poked her head in, grinning.

"What?" Alex spat, not in the mood for her crap right then.

She giggled and came in, shutting and locking the door behind her.

"I just wanted to see if you had fun," she said, smiling widely.

"Last night?" Alex asked. "Yeah, a blast, thanks." She turned over and faced the wall.

Unaffected by her foul mood, Toni came over and jumped into bed with her.

"I wasn't talking about last night, but you're right, we should cover that first. Did you like all the attention?" she asked.

"Do you really not remember what you did?" Alex asked, turning over.

"What I did?" Toni asked, backing up a little as she saw how upset Alex truly was. "I'm not sure I follow. Did we move back to talking about today? Wade wouldn't have really come in here and fucked you while you were sleeping, Alex."

"Not today," Alex clarified. "Last night, on the way home."

Toni sighed. "No, Alex. I don't remember anything from the drive home. I remember trying to punch that guy and missing, and then waking up this morning. Why? What awful thing did I do? Did I throw up in the car?" She sounded irritated at being judged by her sister.

Alex sighed and turned back over. "It's not important."

"You can't do that. You can't be mad at me for something, allude to it, and then not tell me what I did wrong," Toni said, pulling at her shoulder. Alex had tears in her eyes when she turned back around.

"Sweetie..." Toni said, her tone changing to one of concern.

"It's fine. If you don't remember, it's not important," Alex said, wiping her eyes.

"Bull shit, it's not important. What did I do?" Toni asked.

Alex sighed. "I know you were drunk, I just figured you would remember. You got a little friendly on the way home."

'Wade brought us home?" she asked.

Alex shook her head. "No Toni, you got a little friendly with me, while I was driving."

Her face was scrunched up in confusion. "What? I did?"

"Yes, Toni, you did," Alex said, turning over.

"I'm... I'm sorry," she replied, the words sounding like a question as she was still clearly not understanding what had happened.

Alex sighed. "Like I said, it's not important."

"Alex, just tell me what I did. I'm sorry but I don't remember anything!" Tony said, growing exasperated.

Alex turned again and looked angrily at her sister. "Well, after yelling to the whole party that I don't masturbate, which actually sounded more like, "mathermate," you proceeded to try and demonstrate how on the drive home."

Toni looked at her flatly for a second. "And that's what you're mad at me for?" she asked. "I just made you watch me..."

"You didn't try to demonstrate on yourself..." Alex said, finally silencing her.

Toni struggled to comprehend for a moment. "I... uh... I'm sorry," she said, "What exactly did I do?"

Alex sighed. "Do you want a play by play or something? It was inappropriate. I was driving and couldn't really fight you off."

Toni swallowed. "So... I touched you?"

Turning, Alex looked over at her, very irritated. "You shoved a finger inside me, only after trying to use your tongue. I was holding your head at bay when you decided to pull my panties away and finger me."

Toni, shocked, could only shake her head and sit in silence.

Alex turned over and faced away from her. A long minute of silence filled the room. Hearing sniffles, she turned and saw a few tears coming from her sister's eyes. She sighed and sat up.

"Toni..." she said, her voice softening considerably.

"I'm sorry..." Toni stammered, quietly. "I really didn't know that happened."

Alex could see that she was deeply bothered by what she'd apparently done. Her heart breaking, Alex pulled her sister in for a hug. She immediately felt guilty for berating her. Toni was the more fragile of the two. Alex was supposed to protect her and here she was causing her grief. She pulled her down in bed with her, and spooned up behind her.

Toni spun over after a few minutes and began to play with Alex's long hair.

"If it's any consolation," Alex whispered. "You did give me an orgasm."

Toni looked at her like she'd said she was pregnant. "How is that supposed to make me feel better?" she asked.

"Sorry," Alex said. "I guess that was dumb."

"All I need to know is that you're okay," Toni said, looking directly into her eyes.

Alex returned the stare and forced a smile. "I'm okay, Toni. I promise."

That seemed to make her feel better, and she leaned her head down to nuzzle under Alex's neck. Pulling back a few seconds later, Alex looked down at her. "Can I ask something, though?"

Toni nodded.

She cleared her throat. "Are you bisexual?" she asked.

Toni smirked. "I was hammered, Alessandra," she said dismissively.

"You were really trying to work your tongue between my thigh and my panties," Alex told her, looking down at her pointedly.

She sighed and shrugged. "You don't wonder what it's like sometimes?" Toni asked.

"What?" Alex asked. "Being with a woman?"

Toni nodded. "Going down on a woman."

Alex coughed and shook her head. "I uh... no?"

"I mean, it's got to be different that going down on a man, you know?" she replied.

Alex shifted uncomfortably, which Toni caught.

"You've never gone down on a boy, have you?" she asked.

"There's lots of stuff I haven't done, Toni. Stop deflecting and answer my question," she said.

Toni shrugged. "I dunno. I've never been with a woman. It's something I figured I'd try in college. I definitely find women attractive. I mean, I'm obviously attracted to you."

Alex shook her head. "We're identical though, I don't know if it counts."

Toni was shaking her head in disagreement. "I can look at myself and feel pretty. I can look at you and feel horny."

Alex blushed and fell silent.

Toni realized what she'd said and grew quiet as well. An awkward silence descended on the two.

"So what did you do today Kenny?" Alex said playfully, breaking the uncomfortable air that had settled on them. "Oh nothing, got fingered by my sister who gets horny just looking at me."

Toni smirked and then laughed, smacking Alex on the shoulder. "I know for a fact that I must turn you on," Toni said, eyeing her.

She rolled her eyes. "How's that?"

"We're cut from the same cloth. We've always been attracted to the same types of boys."

Alex shrugged. "Sure. I find you attractive," she said, sarcastically.

Toni sighed. "Would you like me to prove it to you?" she asked.

Sighing, Alex peered at her with a look of doubt.

Toni quickly slid forwards as Alex's eyes widened. Her soft lips brushed gently across Alex's. They seemed slightly wet, but were warm and intoxicating. A jolt of pleasure shot through her as Toni's tongue pushed into her mouth briefly. Alex sighed and closed her eyes as Toni broke the kiss.

A few moments of silence later, Alex opened her eyes and saw Toni smiling at her.

"That wasn't fair," Alex said, blushing deeply. Toni giggled. Turning over, she snuggled back up to her sister. "You cheated."

Toni shrugged, a grin plastered to her face. "So what did you think about today?" she asked, not turning over.

Alex blushed uncontrollably. "I'm... uh..."

"You had to know that Wade and I have been having sex," Toni said, glancing briefly over her shoulder.

She nodded. "I've heard you guys before."

"So that's when you masturbate, watching Wade and I?" Toni asked.

Alex shook her head. "No, that was the first time I've ever peeked at you two. It was pretty hot and I couldn't help myself."

Toni giggled. "Told you that you were attracted to me."

"Stop it, Toni," Alex said quietly, still embarrassed. Toni spun over, though, intent on twisting the knife a little deeper.