No Reply - Husbands' Response

No, just fuck no

Close to what you would expect to happen.

But still Debbie gets a tradition explained to her, is expected to carry it out, rings her husband explains she knows about it and wants to know if he is OK with it.

He says virtually nothing , so she goes along with it.

While she could have said she wasn't going along with the sick tradition, the husband definitely should have said "Hell NO"

The idiot

Not as well written as the original, but it gives it the ending it deserved.

Not because I like it better (I do), but it is way more inline with the main character developed in the original.

Okay, but some other versions were better.

Good!

Didn't care for the original and this one wasn't any better.

Still a cuck tale untagged at least have the courage to tag your story, it’s good manners here on Lit.

Scores 1/5

Crap.

Interesting fantasy. This author is a woman, as they typically expect their actions are acceptable (they “control the pussy”) and thus the somewhat happy ending. Problem is Men tend to give everything into their love for their wives. The betrayal is crushing to men. Forgiveness (if remotely possible) takes forever.

Additional thought: If the sexes were somehow reversed (men teaching young women), it would be viewed as fantasy and “not plausible”

How do you figure they regained there respect and dignity they let there wives fuck around on them they didn't regain their respect and dignity they lost all respect not just from there wives but from everyone else in the world including kids they can never regain that the husbands and the wives all deserve to die the husbands should kill themselves now cause there not going to like life now there going to get disrespected at every turn from everyone and then there going to get there ass beat by every MAN out there at every turn ask any willing cuck bitch out there they will tell you nobody not even kids respect them that they get there ass beat every time they leave the house they have to live like a recluse for being a willing cuck bitch which is why in real life you hardly ever hear about willing cuck bitches cause they know they will disrespected by everyone and get there ass kicked at every turn and not even the law will do anything to help them that's the price you pay for being something that god did not create man to be that's assuming they even survive most willing cuck bitches wouldn't survive they would be killed like they deserve and the cheating sluts would also be killed like they deserve

Simply terrible.

Nice spin!! You nearly pulled it off. Many nice words and pleasantries for everyone but the victims. Everyone has their own reality and no one should ever think that others would accept or rejoice in their personal reality or hell as the case may be. Sometimes it’s better to be a widower rather than a Divorcee

Not a bad alternative. Comes off as less betrayal than in GA alternative where her reasons are different. To be fair the MC here brings up a good point. She did ask him and he did not reply. Still rough, but not as harsh as GA versions, where she would have done it anyways and she said some things that would effectively kill the marriage. 4 stars as I doubt the other marriages would suddenly heal because trees were removed after so many years of pain.

Have read a bunch of no reply it amazes me how easy the women get off

Not much! No honour anywhere in this story. Strident cunts and wimps.

This was a big no-no. Telling us we have to find somebody else's story without a link. Another way you can do it is to start with a summary. For that reason I am not bothering with your story. I am tempted to score it one star, but that would be wrong. No read, no score.

Try to learn from this.

JPB

This is my second comment on this and I'm going to address the tag line of the story a man can never regain respect when he knew and let his wife fuck another man no man would ever respect him and no woman would either he completely lost all respect it can never be earned again even kids will show him disrespect now he killed every credibility he ever had when he allowed her to fuck another man even when she told him what she was going to do he allowed her to do it and get away with it he just became 1 of the lowest scums on earth not the lowest the scum on earth that title belongs to child molesters but the 2nd lowest scum on earth belongs to a true cuckold those that allow and or let there wife get away with cheating which is what this husband is a true cuckold the 2nd lowest scum on earth he needs to go prison where those in for life make him there bitch like the bitch he is then they would kill him cause inmates don't take kindly to child molesters and cuck bitches which is why those types of people never survive not in prison nor in life so not only did the husband just lose all respect from everyone including kids they signed there own death warrant and when a writer writes stories like this they lose a lot of respect not all but a lot cause it shows they would more than likely allow there wife to get away with cheating on them and you can't trust nor respect someone that would allow that just like you can't trust nor respect someone who would cheat

Wow!! I liked it!!

Interesting ordeal some would say he is a better man others would say he is cuck bitch/coward I fall under the later she would have been out the door and I would have completely disowned everyone that was a part of it and would have beat the shit out of the guy

Sorry to say that, this is a piece of crap story about a bunch of cheating piece of crap women and the punk ass guys that stayed with their betraying, slut asses ...

It's not enough that you're a cuck, you're a liar as well!

Where's the dignity in being cucked and a knowing cuckold? Where's the dignity in being with a slutwife? Where's the respect in getting sloppy seconds?

"I'm sorry, so sorry that I pushed the decision onto you when I already knew the right thing to do. I think that that's why I'm so disappointed in myself." - Yep!

\

"a bunch of well-pleased women who have something they can use to control their men." - I don't see how they can use it to control their men. I'd think it's the opposite, that the husbands can hold their wives cheating over their heads.

what are the odds that an add on to a shit story.. was it self a shit story...

Agree wholeheartedly with the Anonymous comment from 3 months ago starting with "This is way better than George Anderson's alternative version...". A long but well written critique comparing this story (which should be rated higher) and George Anderson's No Reply: Answered. The base story by HDK is a hard one to make work given how outlandish the base story is with husbands who know but unlike Bill, do nothing about it for three generations. Anyways I agree with the Anonymous commenter referred to at the start of this post, that this Debbie is far superior and for her reconciliation is warranted. The other Debbie on George Anderson's story is a cheating bitch. No need to recapitulate what is laid out in the critique below but what the GA Debbie does and says is just hurtful and clearly she planned for a long time to cuckold her husband, thoroughly enjoyed it and was probably looking for a repeat with Jeff Burrows" you ger brother in 18 months. The GA Debbie's rationalizations were tawdry and disrespectful, she clearly enjoyed the sex with the young stud, talking about his shirt refractory period, the constant fucking (even though she contends her husband is a much better lover), and got off on the power trip and the illicit thrill, admitting she was going to go behind his back if he said no. Umm fuck that. Of course GA uses the Amy / flower bed scheme as a deus ex machina, so Debbie comes to feel.his pain and they move on with their marriage. In real life, regardless of the Amy trick, that GA Debbie either gets kicked to the curb or their marriage will never be the same, regardless of how GA ended it. But this Debbie is different. She did not know until the funeral and met the.MIL and Janice and Jeff. She did not know about her son Jason and his cuckolding week. She got sucked into the tradition bullshit and paying forward her "gift" from Janice. This Debbie is remorseful almost immediately after Jeff leaves and probably was during the week, though tellingly not enough to stop once she had started the mentoring sessions, which were described as a few hours during the week, not the implied raging and frequent fuckfest in GA's variant ending. Also this Debbie gave her husband a chance by letting him know ahead of time (unlike other women) and offering him the chance to veto it and actually would have assented to his wishes. Because he felt blindsided and guilty over his time with Janice, he hesitated and couldn't express it and she took it as approval. That sucks and she should have known better but it is forgivable. Again thenfact that she gave him an actual choice, was significant. Remember she gave him a week, though the phone call was right before, probably because she didn't have the guts to do it in person, being a coward. But GA Debbie planned it as an ambush and admitted if he had said "no", she would have done it behind his back soon thereafter anyways, despite having to know if found out, which Bill would have, that their marriage would die. There are other differences based on how they react, their differences in demeanor and attitude when Bill comes back, how this Debbie just wants to apologize and make up for what she did and save their marriage, while the GA Debbie wants him to just get over his male.ego, accept that he got cuckolded and then ends up repeatedly hurting him when they argue. After the initial confrontation and then reclaim fuckfest of HDK, she apologizes, begs him to make love to her, and then offers anything to support his healing, helping him with his mother, Janice and young Jeff. But GA Debbie, who is probably only feeling guilty AFTER she sees her marriage in trouble, focuses on sniping and causing him pain and telling him to just suck it up, until she gets the wind taken out if her completely when he rigs the Amy / flower bed stunt. GA Debbie was a piece of work and no better than many of the other cheating slut wives on this site. The tradition was her cover to have an affair and maybe have another until her husband disabled her of that notion and they came perilously close to divorce. This Debbie is nothing like that and can and should be forgiven and the reconciliation is indeed warranted and the emphasis is on Bill's relationship with his mother the schemer who has injured or killed multiple marriages. Those women who refused to remove the trees are loathsome in that they fixate on the memory of their week long trysts with the young studs. In some ways no better than Linda from February Sucks who waxes fondly and lustfully about her one night tryst with Marc the asshole because the sex was do cosmic. Not sure that cheating wives realize how hurtful their praise or extolling the pleasures of their extramarital sex is to a husband. If there is no video or audio evidence then even if the sex was rocking, maybe in part due to the illicit thrill sex multiplier, they need to lie their ass off if they hope to stay married. If they don't, good fucking luck. That is a fact. And even if caught on tape depending on what happened and circumstances, they should still aim to soft sell the sexual pleasure because it is a big fucking deal to a husband. There was none of that with this Debbie and no need for her to lie. She was honest and there was no threat to the Bill sexually. GA Debbie just wants to score points in their arguments, has no problem.hurtijg her husband, and even if honest that her husband is a much better lover but the week met all her expectations (including fucking Jeff that next morning and afternoon after it was supposed to be over, meaning 8 days) because she enjoyed the youthful vigor and stamina and high frequency fucking, she just has to open her big fat mouth and get digs in on her husband, pushing their marriage to the brink. Maybe for someone who is a cheating slut, yet feels guilt on the inside and cannot bring herself to apologize till the Amy incident, that isnwhynshe lashes out but that just means GA Debbie is really stupid when emotional.

Whores that deserved burning is what they were.

Reflection of real life. Far too many fatherless boys in female led households. Hell, all most boys see until age sis teen or more is female authority, single mom, 85%female teachers, 70%female guidance counselors and so on. So society gets what it makes, increasing numbers of submissive males, wiling cucks are on the rise, and much more. And for the anon two comments down, your comments are correct, because GA is on record as stating that women should be for given and allowed to do WHATEVER THEY WANT, no matter how egregious, because, well, that is the way it should work. The stories by that pretend writer reflect that attitude and concept to a sickening degree.