Staying Close to My Sister Ch. 03

The pressure in my chest lessened as my heart rate declined a bit. I took a few deep breaths before asking, "What made you suspect us?"

"It wasn't exactly obvious; I guess I just have a keen eye. You two always acted so friendly with each other. No, friendly isn't the right word. You just seemed close. That's not right either, since you two have been really close ever since your parents' divorce. I think intimate is the right word. Obviously it wasn't outward and flirty, but you seemed to have a deeper connection than you let on. That alone wasn't enough to bust you, but your affair in the living room sure was." She finished with a smug smile.

"Fine, you caught us, but since I admitted everything can you at least tell me why you act the way you do? Do you hate your mom or something?"

Her smile faded into a thoughtful grin. "Of course I don't hate her, but I could see how you would think that. The truth is, I love my mother very much. I started acting weird back when my parents were still together. She worked so hard to make their marriage work, even though by that point she absolutely hated my father. Honestly, I hated him too; he was lazy and rude, and a total womanizer. She wouldn't leave him though, because she thought kids needed to be raised by both a mother and a father. She has really traditional views about stuff like that."

"Yeah, she kinda seems like a prude to me."

"Maybe a little, but I know she only acts that way because she thinks it's best for me. She would never leave that asshole, so I had to step in and make him leave. All that stuff you've heard about, I did it to chase him away. I knew he'd eventually get tired of it and leave us."

"That's why you poured soup on the TV?"

"You heard about that one?" She cringed.

"Your mom likes to vent sometimes. Now it makes sense though."

"Yeah, I have to admit, that one does seem especially crazy. Thank you for understanding why I had to do that stuff."

"Yeah, now that I know the reason, it actually seems pretty cool. But there's still one thing I don't understand. Didn't they divorce years ago? Why do you still act that way?"

"Well, I didn't want her to think I was only acting that way to break them up, so I acted a bit eccentric afterward. I stopped the malicious stuff though, and the other weird stuff was pretty fun."

"Like wishing the Sun good morning, like you did earlier?"

"Yeah, just little stuff like that. She never associated my weird behavior with intentionally trying to break them up. I kept it toned down up until I went to college. Since her job didn't pay that much, Sally had to get an extra job to make ends meet. She worked around sixty hours a week for several months during my first year at school. She seemed miserable, with compounding stress between both jobs and helping me with my schoolwork. I couldn't bear seeing her like that, so I decided to drop out. I told her it was because the classes were giving me bad vibes, because if I told her I dropped out for her sake, she would beat herself up over it."

"Wow, that's really nice. I had no idea you'd go that far for her."

"Yeah, and that brings us back to the eviction. We got a new landlord and she was a real bitch if you know what I mean. She would jump down Sally's throat for anything. If we put our garbage in the wrong bin, or made just a little too much noise, even if nobody complained about it, she would chew her out and add a fee to her monthly rent. Sally was late on a couple of payments a while ago and that bitch threatened to evict her if she was late again. She picked up another job again to make sure every payment was on time, but when she started coming home late because of working two jobs, the fucking landlord lady took another jab at her. She would bitch about how Sally would slam her car door at two in the morning, and how she would have lights on 'disturbing the neighbors' at night, even though no one ever complained. And, of course, she bitched about me a lot too. I don't know why she bitched at us so much, but if I had to guess it was probably because she has a tiny dick." I chuckled at Amanda's rude humor. "Anyway, I think she picked on us because there wasn't a man in our household, so we were easier to bully. She picked on a couple other single mothers as well."

"So did you end up getting evicted because she was a bitch?"

"No, I doubt she would have evicted us for that bullshit she would bitch about, but it made Sally worry, which wasn't gonna fly for me. I took matters into my own hands, and got us evicted myself."

"Why? Wasn't there an easier way?"

"I tried to talk Sally into moving, but she didn't want to make me move again. She's always so worried about messing up my life, even if I'm the one who wants to do it."

"So everything you do is for her sake?"

"Pretty much, yeah."

"Sorry Amanda."

"About what?"

"I always thought you were bat-shit crazy, and I didn't really like you. Now I see you in a whole new light, and I just wanted you to know that I'm sorry I got the wrong impression."

"Well, I can't really blame you for thinking I'm a weirdo, but if you're really feeling apologetic then answer me a question."

"Sure, fire away."

"Are you fucking Judy too?" My chest clinched up again, and my face flushed red once more.

"Wh- where did that co- come from?" I sputtered.

"Oh, don't play stupid. You seem really close to her too, and it doesn't seem like a mere coincidence that she and Lizzy both got pregnant at the same time. Also, the fact that she was so vague about it leads me to believe that she's trying to cover it up. The only problem is; I haven't actually seen you two together yet."

"That's because we're not together!" I couldn't believe it was so easy for her to guess at my relationships.

"C'mon Ray, we're being open with each other, remember? You can tell me. It's not like I'm going to judge you for it. I actually think it's kinda hot."

I thought about it carefully; Amanda clearly wanted to know what kind of relationship we had, and after hearing about her past, I realized that she would do quite a bit to get what she wants. Also, she didn't seem malicious at heart, so I figured it might be better to be up-front with her.

"Fine," I slowly responded. "you caught us. It started with Lizzy at first. When our mom caught us, one thing led to another and she joined in. Now we even have two girls at work who want in on the action. The four of them claim to be my 'harem'."

"Holy shit, I didn't expect all that, but thanks for being honest with me. It means a lot." She reached over and grabbed my hand. Curling her fingers between mine, she added, "Do you think you could do me a favor?"

"I guess." I didn't like where this was going.

"I want you to fuck my mom."

"WHAT?!" I almost screamed. I couldn't believe my ears.

"I know it sounds weird, but let me explain. She hasn't seemed happy in a long time. Back when I was a little girl, when she and my dad got along, she seemed so happy. I wouldn't realize all this until much later, but she loved having a man around, cooking and cleaning for him, and having sex for sure. Once my dad became an alcoholic things started to fall apart, but in those early years she seemed so happy."

"So you want me to replace him? You're starting to sound crazy again."

"No! At first I was just going to ask you to have sex with her. I knew you were fucking Lizzy, and I suspected you might be fucking Judy as well, but that's all I was gonna ask of you. But now that I know about this 'harem' you have, I thought you could make her a part of it. I don't want you to replace him, I want you to be better than him. It would make her so happy!" She finished with a dazzling smile.

"Okay, let's assume I say yes. Do you think your overly traditional, prudish mom is going to jump on board the harem train? Do you think she's going to indulge in depraved acts of incestuous group sex and possibly even have my children? Yeah, I don't think so either."

"I told you," Amanda spoke with worry in her voice, "she's not really prudish. Everything she does is for me, just like everything I do is for her. So if she thinks that joining your harem is what's best for me, she'll do it without a second thought."

"I don't see how she'd think fucking me would make you happy."

Amanda paused for a moment, then seemingly changed the subject. "Ray, I don't think I told you how I got us evicted." She held my hand tighter as she slipped her free hand down her abdomen. "I liked to sunbathe at the apartment complex's public pool." Her fingers slid underneath the waistband of her shorts. "One day, I made sunbathing just a little more fun." I was breathing heavily, eyes fixed on my cousin's gorgeous body before me. "I decided I was sick of these pesky tan lines, so I slipped off my bikini and let my whole body bask in the bright hot Sun." Her hand moved rhythmically inside her shorts, and her breathing became erratic as she tried to finish her story. "Some of the other residents noticed, and it was making me sooo hot being exposed like that." She pulled her hand away from mine and used it to pull her shirt up, exposing her big braless breasts. They were smaller than the others in the family, but still plenty big, with beautiful pink areolas. "I love being watched, especially out in public." She tugged her shorts down to her knees, exposing her panty-less cooch, which glistened in the bright sunlight, crowned by a well-trimmed patch of fur. "I love the thrill of doing this out here. This is exactly what I did to get us evicted."

"Aren't you scared you're going to get caught?" I asked, knowing full well that I thought this was hot as hell too.

"No, that's exactly what I want. Join me, and let's get caught together."

"First, tell me why you're doing this."

"Because," she started, pausing to let out a strained moan, "I need Sally to join your harem, but the only way she'll join is if I'm already in it. I'm seducing you." She finished by showering the grass with her cum, her face painted with serene bliss.

"That's an interesting way to seduce someone." I said as I examined the heaping quantity of cum she had sprayed on the warm ground.

"Looks like it worked though." She replied with her eyes locked on my crotch. By now I had quite the noticeable bulge bursting against my pants. Amanda's satisfied expression reverted back to hunger as she leaned closer to me. "C'mon Ray, let me see that monster!" Our hands met at my pelvis, as I unfastened the button and she pulled the zipper. "One sec." She said as she pulled her clothes the rest of the way off. "You do it too."

"Aren't you afraid we'll be caught?"

"They're not looking this way. Plus, even if we do get caught, it'll make it waaay hotter." She cooed with a devious smile. I was really nervous, but also really turned on. I decided to worry about the consequences later as pulled off my shirt. I wasn't that impressive to look at from the waist up, but I elicited a 'wow' from Amanda as I pulled my pants and underwear off.

"It's a little cold out here." I joked.

"That would look impressive in a freezer." Amanda giggled, "Do you really fuck Lizzy and Judy with this thing? And look at your balls, I've gotta see you shoot!" She reached her hand over and started to stroke me gently. I noticed her hand was still wet from her pussy juice, which provided an excellent lubricant. Leaning back against the tree, I let my worries melt away. So what if we got caught? It wouldn't be a big deal; we would probably just run away.

After a few minutes Amanda started picking up the pace. Her hand delicately cascaded against every bump and vein. Every few thrusts she would rub the tip, sending bursts of pleasure up my spine and re-lubing her hand with slick pre-cum.

"This cock is sooo fucking big; I can't wait to have it inside me." She moaned. I noticed her other hand moving against her clit, as she furiously coaxed both of us to cum. "It's beautiful too. I'm jealous of those girls keeping this a secret. From now on I want to get fucked at least twice a day."

"Lizzy and Mom might not approve of you joining the harem." I pointed out.

"That doesn't matter Ray. The only thing that matters is what you want. Don't tell me you wouldn't like seeing my belly swell up with your baby. Don't tell me fucking me and Sally at the same time wouldn't get you off so fucking hard. If you let us join, I guarantee you'll drown in a sea of pussy, and love every second of it." While speaking, she pumped faster and faster until her hand was a blur. "Do it, fuck mother and daughter until we're full of your seed! Bloat us with your precious babies and make us your filthy cum buckets! I'll be happy if Sally's happy, and Sally'll be happy if you shove your fuck stick inside her and fill her womb with your thick hot cum!"

I couldn't take it anymore, and sent jet after jet of cum blasting upwards in an arc and landing a couple feet in front of us, forming a nice pearly white puddle.

"Holy shit how much do you cum? It's still going too!" She cried as jizz still spurted up and painted the grass before us. "Oh my god, you could fill a two-liter bottle with this! How is this even possible? Is this how Lizzy and Judy got pregnant?"

"Yep, I knocked them both up in the same night." I said as I relaxed from my orgasm and let the last remnants of cum drizzle down my manhood. "And try to keep it down, the people at the park might hear you."

"I don't care about that; I want this in me now!" She squatted in front of me with her back towards me and pressed her hot pink pussy against the warm red tip of my dick.

"Are you sure you want this?" I asked with genuine concern.

"At first I was just doing this for Sally, but now I need it too. I've pleasured myself plenty, but I've never given myself to anyone. Thanks for being my first!" She impaled herself on me, ripping through her hymen, all the way to the bottom. Her body convulsed, as she stammered, "Just like pulling off a band aid."

"You were a virgin?!" I asked with a shocked expression.

"Yeah, thanks for taking care of my cherry." Let me acclimate for a while. We spent several minutes with me pushed all the way up to her cervix. She laid her back against my chest and I rubbed her shoulders. Fortunately, no one seemed to notice our presence thus far, so we took our time and played it slow. Right at first, she would wince every time my cock twitched, but over time her winces turned into moans and my massage migrated from her shoulders to her breasts. Eventually, I was gladly groping my cousin as she slowly grinded her pussy against my cock, both of us moaning and grunting at the gentle stimulus.

"Okay, I think I'm ready for you." She said softly. "Make me your woman. One of them I mean." She corrected herself. I released her tits, sliding my hands down her sides and gripping her hips. I started to pump up and down, slowly at first, but building in tempo.

"Holy shit! This is amazing, I can't believe how good your dick is inside of me! Please let me feel this every day! Sally would love this too! I can't wait until your fucking me and my mom! We can have all the threesomes you want! No, wait. You still have to fuck your sister and your own mom as well. Four girls at once, do you think you can handle it?"

"I think you've forgotten about the two girls I have at work. I've already had a five-way."

"Oh, right! Now you get seven! Lucky you! Or should I say lucky us?"

"I think everyone is lucky with these arrangements."

"Do you think our children are going to be happy living with such wild parents?"

"I hope so; the other girls are already talking about fucking our daughters."

"OH MY GOD! OH FUCK FUCK FUCK! THAT'S SO FUCKING HOT!" Amanda screamed as she squirted, spraying it over the puddle of cum I created a few minutes earlier. "YES, DO IT! KNOCK ME UP TOO SO YOU CAN FUCK OUR DAUGHTER! KNOCK HER UP WITH YOUR OWN GRANDDAUGHTER! I WANT THIS SOOO FUCKING BAD!"

I was close, so I pushed her forward so that she way laying doggie style and started to drill her sloppy wet cunt. I expected her to catch herself, but she didn't expect it and fell face first into my cum puddle. As she pushed herself up, her face and tits were covered in my sticky goo. At first I thought she might be mad, but she continued screaming, "OH YEAH, FUCK ME LIKE A BITCH! COVER ME IN YOUR CREAM! DROWN ME IN IT! FUCK ME SOOO FUCKING HARD!"

I thrusted even harder, causing her arms to give way and her face and chest to land back in the cum puddle. "How does it taste?" I asked jokingly.

To my surprise she licked the cum off the ground and reported, "It tastes sooo fucking good! It's thick and creamy, and sweet and salty and bitter and the best thing I've ever had! I can't wait for my mom to try it too!" I grabbed her pig tails and pulled her face out of the cum puddle, eliciting a loud scream of, "Oh yeah! You're so rough with me! I fucking love it!"

"You shouldn't be so loud. The people at the park might hear us."

"That's the point! There's a thrill in the chance of getting caught, sure. But the real thrill is in really getting caught. I want someone to walk by and see my cunt getting turned inside-out by your monster cock!" I wasn't on board with her plan, but I had to admit that getting caught might be kind of fun.

Right on cue, two people turned the corner around a group of trees and came into direct view. They were about fifteen feet away and staring right at us.

"Oh my god, are they fucking out here?" One of them asked the obvious question. They looked like twins: both had light brown hair down to their shoulders, meeting their blue and white tracksuits. Both were in superb shape, probably because they seemed to be runners, and both had average sized breasts. Currently their most prominent feature was their faces, one wearing a look of stunned surprise, the other painted with fervent disgust.

I was on the cusp of pulling out and running, but Amanda had other plans. "Oh yeah! I'm getting raw dogged right now by this fucking stud! Keep going baby! Keep fucking my cunt while those bitches watch!" I didn't think it was a good idea, but I trudged on, plunging deep again and kissing Amanda's soft little cervix.

"We should go," the girl with the look of disgust stammered, "I don't want to see this anymore." The girl with the look of surprise was slow to answer. Her face faded from surprise to a faint longing as she watched me plunge into Amanda's frothing pussy. "C'mon," the disgusted girl pleaded, "let's just leave!"

"I don't know," the other girl said, "look at his thing." Her last comment was a mere mumble, a barely audible, "I bet that would feel so good inside of me." Her legs pulled together and her breathing became erratic.

Despite all her moaning, Amanda was able to make out what she words, replying, "It doesn't feel good, it feels incredible! Every bump and every vein on his horse cock scrape against my poor little snatch! See all this cum on the ground? That was his first load, and he's about to send his second right up my fertile womb!"

"Interesting," the aroused girl said, "it's very fitting to be outside when you breed like animals." She rubbed her crotch as she approached.

The disgusted girl screamed, "WHAT THE FUCK ARE YOU DOING? STAY AWAY FROM THEM!"

"Don't be that way." she didn't even turn to look at her companion as she spoke. "It's not like they're hurting anyone."

"Yeah!" Amanda cried through her moans. "Everybody wins with his cock! I bet you want to feel it surge inside you and knock you up too! My cousin's cock is amazing!"

The disgusted girl looked mortified as she screamed, "OH MY FUCKING GOD! THEY'RE RELATED?"

The other girl looked surprised again, but quickly shifted back to arousal. "Don't be so closed minded," she said, "no love is wrong." She fell to her hands and knees in the puddle of cum, making her tracksuit a little less blue and a little more white. Face to face with Amanda, she cooed, "Go for it; get knocked up with your cousin's baby. Do it girl!" Amanda leaned forward and met her lips, sharing a kiss as my dick prepared it's second shot.