That Old Comeback

PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

"That was incredible!" Theo said, breaking the silence. He glanced around to make sure they were still alone - thankfully they were; it seemed their gasping and moaning as they came had not awoken anyone in the house. "Seriously one of the best fucks I've ever had!"

Ayesha grinned, feeling like a woman half her age. "You're so sweet..."

"I mean it," Theo said, serious despite the wide smile on his face. "I've never fucked a woman like you before, Ayesha. God... I might not fuck you every day, but it's not gonna be from lack of trying!"

"Hmm... I might be getting busy in the next few weeks..." she said, slyly. "I've got a lot of catching up to do... so many guys... so little time... and a husband to keep blind."

"True... I can help with that," Theo said. "Being fairly proficient myself at keeping significant others in the dark... So who's next on your list? Kyle?"

"Oh definitely," she said, biting her lip at the thought of fucking Kyle Mattews.

"Bet he won't be as good as me," Theo said smugly.

"We'll see..."

Theo couldn't help but smile with her. This woman's lust was infectious! "So... where next?"

Ayesha bit her lip with horny anticipation. She could feel Theo's cock was still hard and ready for more - just like Brad had been so many times - and she was likewise turned on and down to fuck. The sofa was now a cum-stained mess - thankfully she could just turn it over until she had a chance to dump it all into the wash. Like she had done in the living room with the sofa that she and Brad and fucked atop for ages.

Rising unsteadily to her feet - Jesus, her legs felt so weak! - Ayesha gestured with a finger for him to follow her. An idea had resurface; one that she had thought of when having sex with Brad all those times. There was place they had started, but never fully defiled with their hot fucking.

Curious and eager, Theo followed Ayesha as she led him into the house via the kitchen door.

Leaning back against the kitchen island, Ayesha stroked the surface. "Strange to think," she said softly, "that I sucked Brad's cock here a half-day ago." That thought sent her head spinning: over twelve hours ago she had been on her knees sucking Brad Newell's huge cock in this very kitchen! She had sucked him and tit-fucked him until he had pumped her mouth full of his cum.

"Did you swallow?" Theo asked, grinning as he took in this horny woman standing before him.

"I tried," Ayesha said, pretending to be upset. "But he pumped so much! It got everywhere. All over my tits. I had to take everything off."

"Such a shame," Theo said. "Luckily you're not wearing anything right now."

"No," Ayesha said. A wicked smile springing to life on her face. It amused her to see his cock twitch in reply. This hung twenty-five-year-old was so hot for her, and that turned her on even more. "Do you want to fuck me on this counter, Theo? Brad never did. He never fucked me out on the patio sofa either. I want you to give me some new experiences. I want you to fuck me in all the places Brad didn't."

"His loss is my gain," Theo said as he walked to her. Placing his hands on her hips, Theo took a moment to admire her horny expression before pulling her close and kissing her passionately. Their tongues entwined as he picked her up and placed her on the counter, climbing up onto it as she lay back.

Within moments Theo had placed both hands on the surface of the kitchen island, and with her legs wrapped around his waist had pushed himself back into her warm, tight pussy - now filled with his warm spunk - and was pounding away with the same intensity as they had been fucking previously.

Holding his head in her hands, Ayesha held her lips to his as she felt his huge cock piston into and out of her. She was afraid to break the kiss, lest her moaning be heard by her family: all of them peacefully asleep upstairs. Completely unaware of the hot, sordid sex the matriarch of the household was currently enjoying with her daughter's boyfriend.

And enjoying the sex she was! Sex with Brad had been an incredible reawakening of her slutty old self; a romp of self-discovery, as it were. However this was cementing her new status as a cheating bit of MILF ass. Theo would be just the start of something incredible; Ayesha knew it. Next would be Kyle Matthews, that hunky, sexy mix of Italian-Celtic hotness. She would ride his big dick until he filled her with his cum, and she would compare him to his friend and this stud of a man currently nailing her to the kitchen island.

Then... then she would see where life would take here. There were so many cheating guys in the city to be found, and so many young singletons with a mission to prove themselves the best at fucking. Ayesha wanted to find them all, and taste all of them on her lips.

Meanwhile Theo was on a mission! His hips were almost a blur as they pounded her ass. A veritable jackhammer of gym-honed musculature and testosterone-fuelled need to prove himself the best fuck she ever had.

Ayesha appreciated the effort he was making. Especially as his massive cock was pistoning up another intense orgasm with the way he was corkscrewing his motions. Giving her his dick from different angles of attack.

"You like this?" Theo grunted as he slammed his hips down again and again. Plunging his rock hard cock balls deep and pounding her cervix with the warm, sensitive tip of his dick. "You like it when I fuck you like this?"

In answer she dropped her legs from their vice-like grip around his waist and planted them on the surface of the kitchen island. Using her own considerable strength Ayesha began to thrust up to meet him. Countering his erotic aggression with her own lust-fuelled need to cum, and feel him cum inside her again.

"Fuck yeah!" Theo said, grinning with how hot this all was. "Yeah, you love it! You love taking my cock! You love how big it is, and how hard it is!"

"Yeah, I love it!" Ayesha replied, her eyes blazing with need for his dick. "I love how you make me feel, Theo! I love how hard you are, and how big your cock is! I need your cock, Theo! Make me cum! Make me cum like only you can!"

"Did Brad make you cum like this?" Theo asked, hammering away with his thick shaft.

"Does it make you jealous?" Ayesha said, loving how she could taunt this hung stud with other alpha males. "He's just as big as you! He cums so much! He made me cum hard!"

"Does he make you cum as hard as me?" Theo grunted. Oh he definitely wanted to prove to her that he was the better fuck. He wanted Ayesha Khan to call him whenever she wanted sex, not Brad Newell. Let Brad fuck other women (and the guy was attractive enough to get laid with no problem, Theo was sure): Theo Miller wanted to fuck his girlfriend's hot mum. He wanted to nail Ayesha Khan against anything and everything in this large house of her husband's. His was the number she should be dialling whenever she was in the mood for a booty call.

God, Theo wanted to nail this hot stunner against everything in the house. The kitchen was just the start: he wanted to fuck her in every room, on everything they could find. He wanted to fuck her in her daughter's room. Fill her up with his cum where his girlfriend slept. Holy shit, he wanted to make her husband watch! Let him see how his wife needed to be fucked!

That thought was on Ayesha's mind as well; what if Yusuf saw them as they were now? With Theo Miller on top of her, hammering away like a man possessed (and he definitely was: filled with the burning need to make her cum, and perhaps cum again like he had ten minutes ago).

Oh dear God; she wanted to cuck her husband so bad! It wasn't enough that she was taking a hung stud's cock behind his back. Cheating on her husband of some twenty-odd years. No, she needed to properly humiliate him, for making her put up with his pitiful nonsense all these years.

She...

No. All in good time. Ayesha Khan wanted to explore her sexual possibilities first. There were so many good-looking men in Coytoss, and probably Eroshire as a whole. She wanted to taste them all, with the security of her marriage still intact. Besides, it made the sex a whole lot more sexier knowing that he husband was completely oblivious to her cheating.

Let him live in blissful ignorance a while longer.

Harder and harder she bucked her hips to meet Theo's powerful thrusts. Helping him plunge all nine-and-a-half-inches of thick cock straight into her needy, lusty, and very cum-filled pussy. The force of his penetrating thrusts squeezed out all the thick gunk he had emptied into her earlier, and creamy globs dripped onto the surface of the kitchen island.

"Does he make you cum as hard as me?" Theo asked again, grinning as sweat dripped from his forehead onto her face.

"What's the matter, Theo?" Ayesha purred. "Feeling the lesser man? Out-fucked by a teen?"

His smile widened. "Nah. 'cause I know I've got the better cock! I bet I filled you up more than he ever did!"

"You did," she said seductively, and she couldn't help but smile when she saw his eyes widen in triumph. "You filled me up more than Brad did. How does that make you feel, Theo? Knowing that you cum more than my son's stud friend?"

"Feels great!" Theo said, hammering away with his hips. It felt so good to be back inside this hot forty-four-year-old. Pleasing her with the best sex she ever had, after a day fucking and sucking a big dick nineteen-year-old! He was going to show Ayesha Khan a great time tonight, until the sun rose. Having thought he was going to score some boyfriend points with Syeda after embarrassing her at work earlier today, Theo had no idea this evening would turn out to be so fucking hot! And he had spent hours earlier fucking his gorgeous thirty-seven-year-old boss! As good as Ewa Adamik had been with giving him head, however, having his dick sucked by Syeda's hot mother had been something completely else!

And now they were fucking for the second time this night! They were having sex in the kitchen on the island counter that the Khan family probably ate breakfast! The thought of them all sitting around this kitchen island, eating their breakfast, completely oblivious to the hot sex action that would have happened the night before... Jesus Christ, it was too fucking hot!

Leaning back, Theo gripped her waist and began pounding her with his huge dick faster, giving her a smug look as he bucked his hips back and forth. Plunging his shaft deep into her, until his tip slammed into her cervix.

Ayesha didn't blame him for looking so smug: here he was fucking the mother of his girlfriend. Giving her his dick in ways that he probably never had made love to Syeda. She took after her father, after all. Only far sweeter. Such a caring child. It would break her heart to know that her boyfriend was a cheating slut. A serial cheater who fucked not only his boss and co-workers, all behind Syeda's back, but was now fucking Syeda's mother. The mother with whom she had such a close relationship!

Oh it would probably break Syeda's heart to discover them fucking like this. Yet rather than make Ayesha mortified about what she was doing, it only made her hornier. She was having what her daughter had had for months now, and she was fucking this hung stud better than her daughter ever could. Without a condom, as well!

"Fuck yeah!" Theo growled. "Take my cock you horny slut! How does it feel being fucked by a cock like mine?"

"Oh, it feels so good!" Ayesha moaned. "I love your cock, Theo! Syeda doesn't deserve your cock!"

"No? Who does?" Theo asked, knowing what her answer would be.

She didn't disappoint: "ME! I need your cock, Theo! Give it to me! Don't fuck my daughter! Not when I make you feel better than she does!"

"Yeah, you're right!" He gasped, pounding away. His cock was slamming into her so hard the kitchen island would probably collapse under the force of their fucking! His balls ached; having already brewed up a fresh batch of cum to empty into this horny woman's womb. "God, you feel so good, Ayesha! You're so fucking tight!"

"Tighter than Syeda?"

"Much tighter! God, I love how you feel on my cock!"

"More than Syeda?"

"Yes! I love your cunt more than your daughter's!" Theo growled. Hammering his cock into her with such fury Ayesha was surprised he hadn't broken it! Even Brad hadn't fucked her this hard, even when they had fucked on the stairs! "I'd much rather be fucking you than Syeda!"

"Good, because I want you to fuck me all the time!" Ayesha growled back. "I love your cock! I want you to give it to me every day! Every way possible! We're gonna fuck in every room of this house, Theo! You're gonna fuck me and cum inside me every day, in every room, until you've fucked me everywhere we can. Then we're going to get REAL imaginative!"

Oh that sounded like heaven to Theo! Having sex with Ayesha Khan every day? Fucking her in every position he could think of (and Theo could think of quite a few!). Many of which he had never enjoyed with Syeda? Oh, he was going to be fucking his girlfriend's mother as much as he could, whenever he could, for as long as he could.

And if Syeda found out? That wouldn't stop him. Sex with Ayesha was just too good to let a thing like a broken-hearted girlfriend get in the way. Even if the woman he wanted to have sex with was said broken-hearted girlfriend's mother!

"And then we'll fuck whever I want!" Theo growled. "I'll take you to my work and we'll fuck in all the offices! We'll fuck on the desks and chairs! We'll fuck in the staff room! I'll fuck you in all of the elevators! We'll fuck on the roof! We can fuck in my boss' office!"

"Oh God! Theo!" Ayesha was lost in how hot it would be to be taken into Theo's place of work, only to be used as his cumslut in every way possible. Everywhere in that building! She needed that to happen! Just as she needed to seduce more men, to unlock more hot locations in which to be fucked and filled with more hot cum that her husband could ever manage! "Fuck me! Fuck me and make me cum!"

Again and again his huge cock slammed into her. Sending thick globs of cum flying out. Their fucking had already covered most of the surface with sweat and cum, and Theo hadn't cum for the third time yet!

Speaking of cuming: Ayesha's orgasm was about to erupt. She could feel the familiar ball of pleasure build within her, threatening to explode and take her senses with it. Each time Theo's hot cock head slammed into her cervix Ayesha could feel that ball grow in size, and it was huge now! Huge and ready to erupt into an orgasm that would be her biggest yet!

"Yes! Fuck me Theo! Fuck me! Oh God, I love your cock! I love your huge cock! Fuck me! I want to feel your cock in me every day! I want you to fuck me and make me cum every day! I love your dick! Oh Theo... oh make me cum! Make me cum, Theo! Please! Don't stop! Please! Don't stop making me cum! Don't stop fucking me! Don't stop fucking me and making me cum!"

As she moaned and sang his praises, Theo clutched her hips and slammed his cock into her over and over. Jackhammering her pussy with all nine-and-a-half-inches of thick, hard cock. He was enraptured by the sight of this horny woman writhing on the counter in front of him. Ayesha Khan looked so fucking good being fucked silly by his dick, and Theo was happy to continue to give it to her. Like her husband never could with his smaller, weaker cock.

"Oh fuck, Theo! Fuck me! Oh, I love your dick! I love how good you make me feel! Please! I want you to fuck me! Fuck me and cum in me! Fill me with your spunk! I'm not on birth control, Theo! Cum in me! Make me pregnant with your thick cum!"

Oh, Jesus Christ that was dick-hardening! Theo rammed his cock into her harder and harder. Eager to pump her full of his thick cum for the second time that night! The thought of getting his girlfriend's mother knocked up was just too much, and yet here they were: fucking atop of the kitchen island without protection. He had already pumped loads of his cum into her fertile womb, and Theo was sure as hell that wouldn't be the last time he did so tonight.

Their sex was far from over...

Gasping and breathing heavily, Theo jackhammered his cock into this stunning woman, who bucked her hips violently up to meet him. Together they made a fast and frantic pace, the sound of their bodies slamming together filled the kitchen. Ayesha was, for once in her life, glad that the house was large enough that the sounds of sex was probably lost on those peacefully sleeping upstairs.

"Fuck me, Theo! Fuck me hard! Oh God... I love our sex, Theo! I love how you feel inside of me! I love fucking your cock without a condom! You'll never wear one when you fuck me, Theo! You'll always cum inside!"

"Except when you swallow my cum like a good girl!" Theo couldn't help but interject.

"Hmm... yes," Ayesha loved that thought. "I'll swallow your cum, and you can always cum in my ass as well..."

"Oh fuck, Ayesha!" Theo gasped. That thought hit him like a freight train of sexy. "You know all the right things to say to make a guy cum!"

"I do, don't I?" Ayesha said, a sly grin on her face. "Now hurry up and CUM!"

Gripping the kitchen island edge behind her, she used her powerful muscles to buck her hips up to meet his. Helping him slam his cock into her as hard as possible. It felt so good taking his massive dick without protection; there was no way Ayesha could ever ask a guy like Theo to put on some plastic! No; somehow she needed to either get on the pill (tricky keeping that secret from Yusuf) or have an IUD fitted (luckily there were other practices aside from her husband's who could fit one for her).

And soon. There was no way she could wait days before riding Theo or Brad's big dicks again. Plus there was the matter of Kyle, who would probably be hounding her the moment Brad told him about Brad's lusty day with Ali's mother. And that was just the beginning...

Oh dear God; she was going to have so much sex!

Coming back to the here and now, Ayesha realised Theo was beginning to breathe loudly and deeply, in a manner that suggested to her that he was going to cum soon. She wasn't surprised: although it couldn't have been more than a half-hour since they had started to fuck on the kitchen island, he had been driving his cock into her so hard and fast it was incredible he had lasted this long!

"Going to cum, Theo?" She asked, smirking, although her own orgasm wasn't too far off either at the rate this was going.

"Yeah, fuck!" Theo groaned. "You feel so fucking good! Oh God... I'm going to cum in you! I'm going to fill you with my cum, Ayesha! God, I wish your daughter could see this! Would you like her to watch me fill her mother with my hot cum? Fill you like I've never filled her?"

"Yes! Cum in me, Theo!" Ayesha humped her hips, feeling her own orgasm about to hit too. "I want you to cum in me! Show me what Syeda's missing out on when she makes you wear a condom!"

Gripping her thighs, Theo slammed his cock deep into her again and again. His balls ached with how much cum this lusty - if a little short, by his standards - fuck had brewed. Seeing the expression on Ayesha's face, seeing her lust for his cum in a way few women had ever, was sending Theo hurtling into an orgasm of the likes he had never experienced before!

"Fuck, Ayesha! I love having sex with you!" Theo gasped as he pistoned his dick into her. "So much more than fucking your daughter!"

"Oh yes! I want you to fuck me more than Syeda!" Ayesha moaned. "Fuck me like she'll never let you fuck her!"

Oh, he was doing just that. There was no way Syeda could keep up with the frantic fucking he was giving her mother. His cock was a blur as it pounded into Ayesha's cum-filled pussy, and Theo could feel his balls begin to tighten as his third orgasm of the night was approaching.