This Wasn't Supposed To Happen

Adam finished getting dressed and ran out of the room as fast as he could, slamming the door behind him.

Kara kept the camera aimed at the rumpled bedsheets. The strange, silent image spoke so many words, and the sound of Lisa vomiting into the toilet in the other room became music to her ears. She had done it. The plan was successful. Lisa had been made a fool of, tricked into fucking her own brother, and Kara had it all on camera. As much as she wanted to stick around and listen to Lisa puking, she knew she had to take this opportunity to leave.

She switched off the camera, and then hurried out, excited to tell Megan all about it, during a private screening of course.

Time passed and Kara's plan was coming together. Megan had set the blackmail in motion, Lisa was terrified about the video getting out, and was cooperating. Kara was about to climb the ranks of her sorority overnight, the only freshman to do that. Everything seemed to be going as planned.

Still, the more Kara dwelled on the situation, the more she felt embarrassed at her initial reaction to Jake. He didn't deserve the way she had treated him. He had been just as clueless as her. He was also a lot more mature about what happened and hadn't made a big deal. Maybe some small part of him had even enjoyed it? It was tempting for her to think about.

A weekend soon approached when her parents invited both her and Jake to spend Saturday and Sunday back home and catch them up on how college life was going. Kara decided maybe at some point she could readdress the topics with Jake and find some clarity on the matter. That weekend they both made their way home, and welcomed each other as if nothing had ever happened between them. Kara was relieved.

On Saturday morning, Kara sat on the couch watching tv in her t-shirt and pajama bottoms with a bowl of cereal, just like she had done when she was younger. Jake came by and joined her with a piece of toast. She smiled and moved aside to give him room next to her on the couch.

Soon their mom came in with some news.

"Hi kids," she said, "I hate to do this to you on a weekend where you're visiting, but your grandma can't get into her driveway. Apparently some kids next door are having a party and have blocked her out. She's at her friend's house, very upset," she said.

"Yikes, okay," said Kara.

"Your dad and I are gonna go take care of it and we'll come right back. Okay? We'll probably be back in an hour or two."

"Okay, mom, no problem," Jake added.

After their parents drove away, Jake and Kara finished their breakfast. There was nothing particularly good on tv, and they just lounged about on the couch for a few minutes. Jake couldn't help but notice that Kara didn't bother to put on a bra before coming downstairs. Her breasts moved freely and unrestricted under her t-shirt, and jiggled about when she had set her bowl down. He couldn't help but wonder what they looked like. Thoughts like this had become more common since their accidental encounter together.

Kara suddenly jumped off the couch and ran to the liquor cabinet, to do her favorite thing to do when she was alone at her parents' house. She pulled out a bottle of bourbon and took a swig, then passed it to Jake. They sat back on the couch, laughing, passing it back and forth, and knowing that their parents would never know. Soon they started to feel buzzed.

"Oh, hey..." said Kara, after a stretch of silence, "I wanted to tell you something."

"What's that?" asked Jake.

"I wasn't really fair to you... that day we found out... what we did. I know it wasn't your fault. I was just shocked. I didn't mean to yell at you," she confessed.

"That's okay, I understand, I was shocked too," he replied.

"Yeah but you were a lot more mature about it. Did you really not think it was a big deal?"

"I dunno. I mean, the world hasn't ended since that happened, so whatever." Truthfully, he didn't regret doing it. He had wanted to have sex so badly enough that secretly he was just happy to have had the experience, even if it was with his own sister.

"Okay, cool," she said. She paused for several moments. "I actually didn't think it was a big deal either. I mean, now I don't think it was."

Jake was surprised to hear her apologize, and felt something was up. She wasn't one to do that readily. It was also interesting to hear her say that them having sex wasn't a big deal, especially given her initial reaction. Jake was still frustrated about the whole thing. He had pleasurable memories of what they did together. He wanted more of them. It kept getting in the way that this was his sister he was thinking of, but he couldn't control his feelings.

"Do you ever think about that day?" she asked.

"Yeah... sometimes. It's just sorta unfair," he laughed.

"What's unfair?" said Kara.

"Just... that you... got to see a lot more of me than I got to see of you. Actually, I didn't see anything at all. I have a lot more reason to feel embarrassed than you."

Kara laughed. "I dunno. Yeah, I saw your penis, but also... you know... I had to suck it. That's pretty crazy to think about and makes us even."

"Yeah, I guess."

Kara studied his face. "Are you actually implying that you want to see me naked?" She laughed.

He grinned. "No... I'm just saying, it's not fair that you got to see me and I didn't get to see you."

He stuck his tongue out at her. She stuck her tongue back at him, then smirked. Jake thought for a moment, then said, "I have an idea. I bet I can figure out, within three guesses, which guy in our class you like. If I guess correctly, you have to strip and let me see."

"Haha, there's no way you'll guess it."

"Okay then, if you're so sure, shake on it," he replied. She peered at him cautiously, then reached forward and shook his hand.

Jake ran and got a piece of paper and a pen. "Write his name here," he said, "But don't show me." Kara wrote a name, then folded the paper.

The fact was, Jake already knew who Kara liked. She had told a friend, who mentioned it to someone he knew, and it came up to him in passing later. She had no idea he knew. He just hoped it wasn't a passing thing; that her crush had already been replaced with someone else.

"Jason Nowak!" he exclaimed.

"Nope!" she said, excitedly. "One down!" Jake knew that this wasn't the right answer, but he didn't want to give the right one straightaway, or she might figure out that he knew all along.

"David Martel?" he said next.

"Haha, no," she said, rolling her eyes. "One more guess!" Kara sat up straight, anticipating a win.

"Hmm..." started Jake, "Okay, how about... Ethan Fuller?" Suddenly Kara's eyes grew wide.

"Wha?" she said in disbelief.

"Ha, it's Ethan, isn't it?" Jake said, grinning.

"What the fuck!" said Kara, turning red in the face.

"Show me!" said Jake, trying to grab the paper from her hand. She jumped up and held the paper away. "You have to show me now!" he said, chasing her. He finally grabbed the paper from her hand and she covered her face. He opened it, and it said, "Ethan Fuller."

"I win!" he said proudly.

"Shut up!" she said, sticking her tongue out at Jake again. She folded her arms and looked perturbed.

"Well, let's see then," said Jake, smirking.

"I'm not just gonna get naked all by myself. If I have to do it, you do too," she demanded.

"Fine!" said Jake. They both stood there, unsure how to proceed.

"I'm sure you're really excited to see me naked, but I'm not gonna just strip right here in front of you," she laughed. "You go behind there, and I'll go to the other side, and we'll come out together." She pointed to the tall, stone fireplace that would work as a temporary screen.

Jake and Kara retreated to their sides of the fireplace and hesitantly started to remove their pajamas. As much as Kara was acting out, she was secretly excited to reveal her nude body and to see Jake's again, but she wouldn't admit it to him. She was actually enjoying their playful exchange.

Kara peeked around the corner. "Are you naked yet?" she asked.

"Yeah, are you?"

"Yup.... You go first."

"Fine," said Jake. He took a deep breath and stepped away from the fireplace, and walked into the center of the living room. His penis hung between his legs and bumped against each thigh as it swung. It felt strange to be standing naked in the living room of his parents' house. He felt absolutely naked and exposed. The only sensation that even remotely felt like clothing was the soft rug under his bare feet. Kara watched Jake walk into the center of the room, completely naked. She enjoyed the sight of his penis, and it gave her butterflies.

"Oh man... I can't believe my brother is about to see me butt-ass naked," she laughed. Jake smiled at her, excited by her nervousness. He'd spent so much time estimating the size and shape of her breasts through her clothes, but now he'd get to see them out in the open. He'd get to see his sister's vagina, still a mystery to him, even though he'd been inside it.

"Okay, here goes..." she said. Kara left the security of the fireplace and began to walk out into the room. The shock of seeing his sister with all her clothes removed hit Jake full force. So far, he could only see her in profile as she walked, but there were her breasts, perfectly shaped, jutting out from her chest. They swung gently as she walked forward. Her skin looked so smooth and creamy soft. Her butt was perfectly round and alluring. He watched her butt cheeks shifting back and forth as she moved across the room.

She turned to face him. He was astounded. He stared at her breasts, transfixed. They were soft and round, and had pink, erect nipples that stood at attention, pointing in his direction. He looked down and finally saw his sister's pussy. She had a patch of dark pubic hair that had been trimmed down to a close cropped length. He saw the soft folds of her labia beneath the patch of hair. He remembered how wet and tight it had been. He was speechless.

"Well, here you go," Kara laughed, "You got your wish..." She cupped her breasts and gave them a playful kneading. "These are my boobs!" She let them go and let them bob and settle in place.

Jake laughed. "Very nice!" he said, grinning.

"And... uh... that's what my vagina looks like," she said, looking down.

Jake watched his sister nervously looking between her legs. He could feel an erection coming on, but couldn't stop it. The throbbing started, and his penis slowly rose into the air in front of Kara. She looked up and saw it, then laughed.

"Wow, okay, I guess you really are enjoying this!" She shook her head and smirked.

"I can't help it," he chuckled.

"I know. Man, guys are so transparent sometimes," she giggled.

Kara hurried over to the couch and sat down, where she felt more secure and less exposed. Jake joined her. They sat side by side, not sure what to say. Jake couldn't help but peek to the side and examine Kara's breasts and vagina close up. Kara was well aware of Jake's huge erection sticking out right next to her, and watched it from the corner of her eye. Neither knew what to say.

Finally, Kara said, "It's so weird to be sitting here naked in the middle of the living room!"

"I know!" said Jake.

"I have an idea," Kara added. "Let's run around the house naked. I've never done that before."

"Okay," Jake said. He wondered if she'd have done any of this if it weren't for all the bourbon they drank earlier.

Kara grabbed Jake's hand and led him off through the house. First they walked into the kitchen and got a glass of orange juice together. They stood there, sharing the drink, completely naked. It was thrilling standing on the cold tile floor with no clothes on. Jake couldn't take his eyes off his sister's boobs, and how they swayed back and forth as she walked.

Next they ran upstairs. Jake watched his sister's naked, squishy bottom shift back and forth as she ran up the stairs. He enjoyed the sight of her soft, young breasts bouncing up and down as she worked her way toward the top. She turned and saw him arrive close behind her and laughed at the sight of his penis flopping about as he ran. It was funny to see each other's naked bodies on full display throughout the house, in places where they were supposed to have clothes on. They were giddy like kids again.

They went into Jake's room. He'd been naked a thousand times there, but he never expected to see his own sister naked in his bedroom. She jumped onto his bed, laughing.

"I'm naked on your bed!" she shouted. They laughed. She laid back and stretched out across it. For a moment, Jake got to see Kara's pussy spread open slightly. The soft pink flesh of her inner labia peeked out. She saw him looking at it, became self-conscious, then sat up.

"Okay, let's go to my room!" she said. He was excited to see her get such a thrill out of this. They hurried over to Kara's room and jumped up and down on her bed as well. Jake didn't care this his penis was becoming erect again, and bounced dramatically in front of his sister.

She stopped jumping and laughed, "Ha! Look at your penis!" she said, amused by its movement. Jake laughed back. "Let's go mom and dad's room," she continued.

They continued on through the upstairs to their parent's bedroom. It looked so strange, clean, and formal compared to theirs. They climbed onto their parents bed.

"This is so dangerous," said Kara, snickering.

"Yeah!"

"Can you imagine if mom and dad came home and found us sitting naked on their bed? I'd fucking die. Like, I can't even think about it!"

"Oh my god, yeah." He started to panic. "Maybe we'd better get back downstairs so we can hear them coming if they get back too soon."

"Okay," she replied. They ran back downstairs to the living room and sat on the couch again. Their hearts were racing, set aflutter by the risky tour of the house they took, and the exhibitionist nature of it all.

"That was so funny," Kara said.

"Yeah. I can't believe we did that," said Jake.

After a few minutes, they began to calm down as the adrenaline wore off. Kara and Jake were feeling really connected, having this fun together, in a way they hadn't felt since they were little. They had missed goofing off like this with each other. It was a special friendship, being brother and sister, when it worked.

"Hey," said Kara after a while, "When you said you think about it. What did you mean? What do you think exactly?"

"Oh, um. Are you sure you want to know?"

"Yeah."

"Well for example, I think about when you were... you know... sucking me. How good it felt. I can still sorta feel it, even now."

"Wow, really? I'm impressed at myself!" she laughed.

"You should be impressed! You're really good at that."

"Huh," she said, smiling to herself. "I got cheated though. I should totally make you go down on me as payback!" she joked. She said it as a joke, but she was secretly wondering if he would take it seriously and offer to do that.

"Ha! I guess that would make it more fair," he said. He didn't exactly say yes, but he eluded to the possibility. He didn't want to be the one to take that seriously.

"Ha. Do you... want to?" she asked, cautiously.

"I... guess? I don't mind."

"You don't mind, or you'd like it?" she laughed.

"I'd like it," he said, smiling.

"Hmm.... Okay," she said, "Let's give it a try."

"Really? Okay," said Jake.

He couldn't believe what he was hearing. Kara just agreed to let him eat her pussy. His head was swimming again. He wanted to make contact with his sister again, and now he was about to. Kara laid back on the couch and positioned her head comfortably on a throw pillow. She nervously moved her legs apart to expose her vagina completely. She was afraid at first to open herself in front of him. There were literally no secrets left about her body now.

Jake laid down on the couch over Kara's body, but it was awkward because the couch was so narrow. Kara had to shift around to give him space, and he had to manipulate his body to get close to her. Finally, he was face-to-face with his sister's pussy. He rubbed his fingers over her, feeling the slight roughness of her neatly trimmed pubic hair, feeling her labia separating to receive his fingers in between her outer lips. He spread her open her further and examined the pink flesh inside. It looked so delicate, and was beginning to feel humid. He could smell his sister becoming increasingly aroused. He never imagined he'd be smelling her pussy, and became quickly drunk on her secret pheromones.

He finally leaned forward and began to explore his sister's pussy with his tongue. She shivered at his touch and started breathing audibly. Jake grew excited. His cock started throbbing fiercely. He licked Kara faster and faster. He could feel her clitoris starting to poke out, and knew that he had to stimulate it with his tongue, so he began to work his way around her tingling nub. Kara started to moan, so Jake began to work harder to pleasure her. He could feel her body tense up, and all of a sudden he became coated in a flood of wetness.

"Oh god... Jake..." she said, barely able to speak. He pulled away from her vagina and saw an expression of pure bliss on her face. "Wow... just wow..." she said with pride for her brother.

"Good?" he asked.

"Amazing!" she said. She opened her arms and they hugged. "I love you," she said, feeling very close to her brother.

"I love you too," he said. He never felt such love for his sister, at least not that he could recall. He just wanted to stay like that, holding her close and feel the warmth of her body against his, the softness of her breasts, and the stiffness of her erect nipples against his bare chest.

After they embraced, they looked at each other with fresh eyes. She admitted to herself how much she appreciated her brother, how handsome he actually was, and felt proud to be his sister. He gazed longingly at her, overwhelmed by her beauty, her charm, how close they'd become, so quickly.

"I feel so close to you right now," she said, "I love... spending time with you like this, even if you're my brother." She smiled warmly.

"I feel the same way," he said, smiling back.

"Do you want to... make love again? It's not like we haven't done it before..." she said, nervous about his reaction.

"Yeah, I don't care anymore if we're supposed to do this or not, I love you so much Kara."

Kara threw her arms around her brother and sat up into his embrace. They sat on the couch, hugging and kissing each other for a few minutes. Then Kara grasped her brother's penis and whispered, "Please don't come inside me, since we don't have a condom, okay?" Jake nodded.

She lifted herself slightly, then parted her labia and sat down on his penis. Jake's throbbing cock slid smoothly into her wet pussy and they embraced again. She slowly rode his cock in his lap as they continued to hug and kiss each other, overwhelmed with loving feelings for one another.

Finally she leaned back and stuck her chest out to let Jake cup her breasts as she rode him faster.

"Yes... Jake..." she moaned as her body rose and fell on his, letting his penis penetrate deep inside her. "Your cock feels so good inside me!" She laughed, "My pussy's so wet!"

Jake was overwhelmed with passion, and began to help raise and lower her body on his cock, helping her ride him faster and faster. "Kara! I love being inside your pussy! I want to make you come!" Kara began whipping her hips back and forth frantically, letting her boobs bounce in Jake's face. He tried to catch her nipples in his mouth, finally sucking them hungrily as she grinded her hips against his.

"Fuck!" she screamed out, "I'm coming!" Jake could feel her spasms as her vaginal walls contracted and squeezed his cock. "I'm coming, I'm coming," she repeated wildly. Then finally her head collapsed on his shoulder and her soft hair fell all over him. Jake was throbbing like mad and wanted so badly to come too, but knew he could not. He pulled out of her and then fell back onto the couch together, in each other's arms.